It’s never a good sign when car makers are called before Congress. It’s almost as bad as being asked to visit the President. But last week the meeting didn’t involve allegations or investigations. It was just an occasion for a friendly chat regarding “Self-Driving Cars: Road to Deployment.”
IEEE Spectrum was kind enough to excerpt notable moments from the Q&A which inadvertently highlighted the confusion prevailing among car makers as to the evolution of automated driving. Links to the full video and the IEEE Spectrum report appear below.
The hearing was held before the U.S. House Subcommittee on Digital Commerce and Consumer Protection and included Gill Pratt from Toyota Research Institute, General Motor’s Vice President of Global Strategy Mike Ableson, and Anders Karrberg, Vice President of Government Affairs at Volvo Car Group, along with Lyft’s Vice President of Public Policy Joseph Okpaku, and Nidhi Kalra, Co-Director and Senior Information Scientist, at the RAND Center for Decision Making Under Uncertainty.
Most notable among the responses elicited by the Congressional representatives were some key contradictions which conveyed the impression that the car makers are still seriously flummoxed by automated driving – and possibly less clear headed regarding the regulatory path forward than you might expect. Two issues, in particular, stand out: Level 3 vs. Level 4 development plans and the role of government.
Frank Pallone (D-N.J.) asked: “Volvo has said that it will skip Levl 3 automation and go from Level 2 to Level 4. Can you explain that decision?
Karrberg of Volvo replied: “At Level 3, the car is doing the driving. The car is doing the monitoring. But the driver is the fallback. So, you could end up in situations where the driver has to take back control, and that could happen within seconds. We are concerned about the Level 3 state, and therefore we are targeting Level 4.”
Kalra of RAND agreed: “There is evidence to suggest that Level 3 may show an increase in traffic crashes, and so it is defensible and plausible for automakers to skip Level 3. I don’t think there’s enough evidence to suggest that it be prohibited at this time, but it does post safety concerns that a lot of automakers are recognizing and trying to avoid.”
Reality is that Volvo has already launched its DriveMe project in Gothenburg, Sweden with drivers monitoring the automated driving in a Level 3 style:
http://www.volvocars.com/intl/about/our-innovation-brands/intellisafe/autonomous-driving/drive-me
Soon GM will be on a similar development path with human drivers monitoring the computer driving. Toyota, too, has adopted this vision. Level 3 automated driving is a critical step in the evolutionary path via which humans will “teach” the machines how to drive.
The greatest strength and weakness of Google/Alphabet/Waymo’s approach to automated driving has been the emphasis on driverlessness – no steering wheel, no pedals. This approach rules out the learning process and appears to be a limiting factor on Waymo’s commercial inroads thus far.
In fact, Pratt of Toyota, cast a bit of shade on Waymo in his testimony (without mentioning the company by name) by noting that the data sharing requirements for tracking driver interventions (in California) seems to favor companies taking a particular approach: “It’s the Federal government that we believe should take the leading role. As you may know, in California there’s a requirement, if you’re doing autonomous car development, that you report to the government what your disconnection rate is—every time that your car has a failure of a certain kind. That’s not such a bad idea, but that information then becomes publicly available, and it creates a perverse incentive, and the incentive is for companies to try to make that figure look good, because the public is watching. And that perverse incentive then causes the company to not try to test the difficult cases, but to test the easy cases, to make their score look good.”
But don’t get the idea that Pratt, or any car company, is prepared to fully embrace government intervention in automated driving development. Debbie Dingell (D-Mich) asked: “Are there specific things that Congress should avoid doing that would stifle the development of autonomous vehicles?”
Both GM and Toyota appear to agree that the government role should be limited. Says Ableson of GM: “We wouldn’t want to see [the] government taking steps to specify a specific technology or specific solution. I think as long as we keep in mind that the goal is to prove that the vehicles are safer than drivers today, the NHTSA guidelines published last year are a very good step in that direction, in that they specify what the expectations are before vehicles are deployed in a driverless fashion.”
Pratt of Toyota agreed: “An evidence based approach is really the best one, where the government sets what the criteria are for performance at the federal level, but does not dictate what the ways are to meet that particular level of performance.”
The message from Toyota and GM is clear. Tell us what to do, not how to do it.
These two perspectives are curious in that they conflict with both Toyota’s and GM’s position on the implementation of vehicle-to-vehicle communications currently facing a potential mandate from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. It ws no surprise, then, that Gus Bilirakis (R-Fla.) wanted to know where the respondents stood on V2V tech and how it “fit into the overall blueprint of deploying self-driving cars.”
Pratt took the lead, ultimately calling for preservation of the spectrum set aside for V2V applications: “Vehicle to vehicle as well as vehicle to infrastructure communication is of critical importance to autonomous vehicles. Of course, we drive using our own eyes to see other vehicles, but the potential is there for autonomous vehicles to use not only the sensors on the vehicle itself, but also sensors on neighboring vehicles in order to see the world better. And so, for example if you’re going around a corner, and there’s some trees or a building that’s blocking the view, vehicle to vehicle communication can give you the equivalent of x-ray vision, because you’re seeing not only your view, but also the view from other cars as well… We have to give ourselves every possible tool in the tool chest in order to try and solve this problem. So I think … saving spectrum for that use is also very important.”
In essence, Pratt distills a quite contentious and complex V2V debate into an argument for a government mandate for inter-vehicle communications. Such an argument is only consistent in the context of cellular-based solutions being considered as candidate alternative solutions for connecting cars to each other and infrastructure.
In the end, what emerges is a picture of ongoing confusion regarding the kind of help the automotive industry desires and the roll of Congress or even the U.S. Department of Transportation. It’s worth noting that the Federal Communications Commission is still testing the parameters governing spectrum sharing and an appropriate path forward. Testing of security protocols and standards for V2V are also ongoing.
The lack of a perspective or testimony from either Tesla Motors or Waymo is notable as is the lack of representation from state and local legislators and regulators and organizations advocating (both pro and con) on behalf of consumers – to say nothing of representatives of commercial trucking companies, rental car companies and taxi and limousine associations. In fact, the voices of consumer groups and employers are the ones most missed in this hearing.
If legislators could hear the demand side of the conversation more clearly it would clarify the confusion and contradictions currently ruling the space. Until these voices are heard, car makers will be left to their own aimless devices and regulators and legislators may well go awry creating delays and roadblocks or leading the industry down blind alleys.
Full video of the testimony can be found here: https://www.c-span.org/video/?423974-1/auto-industry-executives-testify-selfdriving-cars
Guests have limited access.
Join our community today!
Join our community today!
You are currently viewing SemiWiki as a guest which gives you limited access to the site. To view blog comments and experience other SemiWiki features you must be a registered member. Registration is fast, simple, and absolutely free so please, join our community today!
Upcoming Events
Search Semiwiki
Instance
Array ( [title] => Recent Forum Threads [title_url] => [ignore_sticky] => 0 [exclude_current] => 0 [limit] => 10 [sluglist] => ["jobs-dashboard"] [rw_opt] => Array ( [widget_select] => 1 [pageid_281769] => 1 [pageid_281772] => 1 ) [display_widget_mobile] => [rw_opt_exclude] => Array ( [pageid_274493] => 1 [cpt_podcast] => 1 [cpta_podcast] => 1 [category_16613] => 1 [category_16631] => 1 [taxonomy_series] => 1 [pageid_354254] => 1 ) [node_id] => Array ( [0] => 2 ) )
Threads
XF\Mvc\Entity\ArrayCollection Object ( [entities:protected] => Array ( [22909] => ThemeHouse\XPress\XF\Entity\Thread Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 51 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Thread [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [thread_id] => 22909 [node_id] => 2 [title] => Foundry Monopoly in leading-edge Manufacturing: is it a real problem? [reply_count] => 40 [view_count] => 3102 [user_id] => 19450 [username] => user nl [post_date] => 1748439822 [sticky] => 0 [discussion_state] => visible [discussion_open] => 1 [discussion_type] => discussion [first_post_id] => 86744 [first_post_reaction_score] => 6 [first_post_reactions] => {"1":6} [last_post_date] => 1748748843 [last_post_id] => 86882 [last_post_user_id] => 14042 [last_post_username] => hist78 [prefix_id] => 0 [tags] => [] [custom_fields] => [] [vote_score] => 0 [vote_count] => 0 [type_data] => [] ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [User] => ThemeHouse\XLink\XF\Entity\User Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 48 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\User [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [user_id] => 19450 [username] => user nl [username_date] => 0 [username_date_visible] => 0 [email] => mauricehmjanssen@gmail.com [custom_title] => [language_id] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [timezone] => Europe/Amsterdam [visible] => 1 [activity_visible] => 1 [user_group_id] => 2 [secondary_group_ids] => [display_style_group_id] => 2 [permission_combination_id] => 8 [message_count] => 186 [question_solution_count] => 0 [conversations_unread] => 0 [register_date] => 1424291496 [last_activity] => 1748754346 [last_summary_email_date] => [trophy_points] => 28 [alerts_unviewed] => 0 [alerts_unread] => 0 [avatar_date] => 1726169369 [avatar_width] => 384 [avatar_height] => 384 [avatar_highdpi] => 1 [gravatar] => [user_state] => valid [security_lock] => [is_moderator] => 0 [is_admin] => 0 [is_banned] => 0 [reaction_score] => 57 [warning_points] => 0 [is_staff] => 0 [secret_key] => V-1lb5_AW69yhzqA5ok9b64U0fMjJiqf [privacy_policy_accepted] => 0 [terms_accepted] => 0 [vote_score] => 0 ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [Forum] => XF\Entity\Forum Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 50 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Forum [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [discussion_count] => 7402 [message_count] => 51241 [last_post_id] => 86882 [last_post_date] => 1748748843 [last_post_user_id] => 14042 [last_post_username] => hist78 [last_thread_id] => 22909 [last_thread_title] => Foundry Monopoly in leading-edge Manufacturing: is it a real problem? [last_thread_prefix_id] => 0 [moderate_threads] => 0 [moderate_replies] => 0 [allow_posting] => 1 [count_messages] => 1 [find_new] => 1 [allow_index] => allow [index_criteria] => [field_cache] => [] [prefix_cache] => [] [prompt_cache] => [] [default_prefix_id] => 0 [default_sort_order] => last_post_date [default_sort_direction] => desc [list_date_limit_days] => 0 [require_prefix] => 0 [allowed_watch_notifications] => all [min_tags] => 0 [forum_type_id] => discussion [type_config] => {"allowed_thread_types":["poll"]} ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [Node] => XF\Entity\Node Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 49 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Node [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [title] => SemiWiki Main Forum ( Ask the Experts! ) [description] => Post your questions to the experts here! [node_name] => [node_type_id] => Forum [parent_node_id] => 1 [display_order] => 1 [display_in_list] => 1 [lft] => 2 [rgt] => 3 [depth] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [effective_style_id] => 0 [breadcrumb_data] => {"1":{"node_id":1,"title":"Main Category","depth":0,"lft":1,"node_name":null,"node_type_id":"Category","display_in_list":true}} [navigation_id] => [effective_navigation_id] => ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [22922] => ThemeHouse\XPress\XF\Entity\Thread Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 55 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Thread [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [thread_id] => 22922 [node_id] => 2 [title] => Pat Gelsinger: AI is a Moral Risk [reply_count] => 12 [view_count] => 1201 [user_id] => 5 [username] => Daniel Nenni [post_date] => 1748484834 [sticky] => 0 [discussion_state] => visible [discussion_open] => 1 [discussion_type] => discussion [first_post_id] => 86785 [first_post_reaction_score] => 0 [first_post_reactions] => [] [last_post_date] => 1748748352 [last_post_id] => 86880 [last_post_user_id] => 332041 [last_post_username] => XYang2023 [prefix_id] => 0 [tags] => [] [custom_fields] => [] [vote_score] => 0 [vote_count] => 0 [type_data] => [] ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [User] => ThemeHouse\XLink\XF\Entity\User Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 52 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\User [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [user_id] => 5 [username] => Daniel Nenni [username_date] => 0 [username_date_visible] => 0 [email] => dnenni@semiwiki.com [custom_title] => Admin [language_id] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [timezone] => America/Los_Angeles [visible] => 1 [activity_visible] => 1 [user_group_id] => 3 [secondary_group_ids] => 4,5,132 [display_style_group_id] => 3 [permission_combination_id] => 88 [message_count] => 13689 [question_solution_count] => 0 [conversations_unread] => 0 [register_date] => 1280720820 [last_activity] => 1748729203 [last_summary_email_date] => 1605968657 [trophy_points] => 113 [alerts_unviewed] => 99 [alerts_unread] => 99 [avatar_date] => 1663211649 [avatar_width] => 110 [avatar_height] => 107 [avatar_highdpi] => 0 [gravatar] => [user_state] => valid [security_lock] => [is_moderator] => 1 [is_admin] => 1 [is_banned] => 0 [reaction_score] => 6726 [warning_points] => 0 [is_staff] => 1 [secret_key] => 0HwyUVVHCwJotUUVEpvqAclfYJdGNPpw [privacy_policy_accepted] => 0 [terms_accepted] => 0 [vote_score] => 0 ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [Forum] => XF\Entity\Forum Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 50 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Forum [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [discussion_count] => 7402 [message_count] => 51241 [last_post_id] => 86882 [last_post_date] => 1748748843 [last_post_user_id] => 14042 [last_post_username] => hist78 [last_thread_id] => 22909 [last_thread_title] => Foundry Monopoly in leading-edge Manufacturing: is it a real problem? [last_thread_prefix_id] => 0 [moderate_threads] => 0 [moderate_replies] => 0 [allow_posting] => 1 [count_messages] => 1 [find_new] => 1 [allow_index] => allow [index_criteria] => [field_cache] => [] [prefix_cache] => [] [prompt_cache] => [] [default_prefix_id] => 0 [default_sort_order] => last_post_date [default_sort_direction] => desc [list_date_limit_days] => 0 [require_prefix] => 0 [allowed_watch_notifications] => all [min_tags] => 0 [forum_type_id] => discussion [type_config] => {"allowed_thread_types":["poll"]} ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [Node] => XF\Entity\Node Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 49 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Node [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [title] => SemiWiki Main Forum ( Ask the Experts! ) [description] => Post your questions to the experts here! [node_name] => [node_type_id] => Forum [parent_node_id] => 1 [display_order] => 1 [display_in_list] => 1 [lft] => 2 [rgt] => 3 [depth] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [effective_style_id] => 0 [breadcrumb_data] => {"1":{"node_id":1,"title":"Main Category","depth":0,"lft":1,"node_name":null,"node_type_id":"Category","display_in_list":true}} [navigation_id] => [effective_navigation_id] => ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [22921] => ThemeHouse\XPress\XF\Entity\Thread Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 59 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Thread [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [thread_id] => 22921 [node_id] => 2 [title] => US restricts chip design software sales to China [reply_count] => 12 [view_count] => 1761 [user_id] => 5 [username] => Daniel Nenni [post_date] => 1748482522 [sticky] => 0 [discussion_state] => visible [discussion_open] => 1 [discussion_type] => discussion [first_post_id] => 86782 [first_post_reaction_score] => 0 [first_post_reactions] => [] [last_post_date] => 1748726512 [last_post_id] => 86878 [last_post_user_id] => 36448 [last_post_username] => Paul2 [prefix_id] => 0 [tags] => [] [custom_fields] => [] [vote_score] => 0 [vote_count] => 0 [type_data] => [] ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [User] => ThemeHouse\XLink\XF\Entity\User Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 52 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\User [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [user_id] => 5 [username] => Daniel Nenni [username_date] => 0 [username_date_visible] => 0 [email] => dnenni@semiwiki.com [custom_title] => Admin [language_id] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [timezone] => America/Los_Angeles [visible] => 1 [activity_visible] => 1 [user_group_id] => 3 [secondary_group_ids] => 4,5,132 [display_style_group_id] => 3 [permission_combination_id] => 88 [message_count] => 13689 [question_solution_count] => 0 [conversations_unread] => 0 [register_date] => 1280720820 [last_activity] => 1748729203 [last_summary_email_date] => 1605968657 [trophy_points] => 113 [alerts_unviewed] => 99 [alerts_unread] => 99 [avatar_date] => 1663211649 [avatar_width] => 110 [avatar_height] => 107 [avatar_highdpi] => 0 [gravatar] => [user_state] => valid [security_lock] => [is_moderator] => 1 [is_admin] => 1 [is_banned] => 0 [reaction_score] => 6726 [warning_points] => 0 [is_staff] => 1 [secret_key] => 0HwyUVVHCwJotUUVEpvqAclfYJdGNPpw [privacy_policy_accepted] => 0 [terms_accepted] => 0 [vote_score] => 0 ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [Forum] => XF\Entity\Forum Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 50 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Forum [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [discussion_count] => 7402 [message_count] => 51241 [last_post_id] => 86882 [last_post_date] => 1748748843 [last_post_user_id] => 14042 [last_post_username] => hist78 [last_thread_id] => 22909 [last_thread_title] => Foundry Monopoly in leading-edge Manufacturing: is it a real problem? [last_thread_prefix_id] => 0 [moderate_threads] => 0 [moderate_replies] => 0 [allow_posting] => 1 [count_messages] => 1 [find_new] => 1 [allow_index] => allow [index_criteria] => [field_cache] => [] [prefix_cache] => [] [prompt_cache] => [] [default_prefix_id] => 0 [default_sort_order] => last_post_date [default_sort_direction] => desc [list_date_limit_days] => 0 [require_prefix] => 0 [allowed_watch_notifications] => all [min_tags] => 0 [forum_type_id] => discussion [type_config] => {"allowed_thread_types":["poll"]} ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [Node] => XF\Entity\Node Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 49 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Node [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [title] => SemiWiki Main Forum ( Ask the Experts! ) [description] => Post your questions to the experts here! [node_name] => [node_type_id] => Forum [parent_node_id] => 1 [display_order] => 1 [display_in_list] => 1 [lft] => 2 [rgt] => 3 [depth] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [effective_style_id] => 0 [breadcrumb_data] => {"1":{"node_id":1,"title":"Main Category","depth":0,"lft":1,"node_name":null,"node_type_id":"Category","display_in_list":true}} [navigation_id] => [effective_navigation_id] => ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [22923] => ThemeHouse\XPress\XF\Entity\Thread Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 63 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Thread [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [thread_id] => 22923 [node_id] => 2 [title] => US court blocks most Trump tariffs, says president exceeded his authority [reply_count] => 16 [view_count] => 1074 [user_id] => 14042 [username] => hist78 [post_date] => 1748492668 [sticky] => 0 [discussion_state] => visible [discussion_open] => 1 [discussion_type] => discussion [first_post_id] => 86795 [first_post_reaction_score] => 3 [first_post_reactions] => {"1":2,"3":1} [last_post_date] => 1748710500 [last_post_id] => 86876 [last_post_user_id] => 38697 [last_post_username] => blueone [prefix_id] => 0 [tags] => [] [custom_fields] => [] [vote_score] => 0 [vote_count] => 0 [type_data] => [] ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [User] => ThemeHouse\XLink\XF\Entity\User Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 60 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\User [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [user_id] => 14042 [username] => hist78 [username_date] => 0 [username_date_visible] => 0 [email] => ckckhcdc@gmail.com [custom_title] => [language_id] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [timezone] => America/Los_Angeles [visible] => 0 [activity_visible] => 0 [user_group_id] => 2 [secondary_group_ids] => [display_style_group_id] => 2 [permission_combination_id] => 8 [message_count] => 3521 [question_solution_count] => 0 [conversations_unread] => 0 [register_date] => 1389969050 [last_activity] => 1748749049 [last_summary_email_date] => 1605978520 [trophy_points] => 113 [alerts_unviewed] => 0 [alerts_unread] => 0 [avatar_date] => 1604959511 [avatar_width] => 807 [avatar_height] => 384 [avatar_highdpi] => 1 [gravatar] => [user_state] => valid [security_lock] => [is_moderator] => 0 [is_admin] => 0 [is_banned] => 0 [reaction_score] => 2992 [warning_points] => 0 [is_staff] => 0 [secret_key] => 2YRSnPrl4fVQSdv3R6uqHxqi6BDQOXve [privacy_policy_accepted] => 0 [terms_accepted] => 0 [vote_score] => 0 ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [Forum] => XF\Entity\Forum Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 50 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Forum [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [discussion_count] => 7402 [message_count] => 51241 [last_post_id] => 86882 [last_post_date] => 1748748843 [last_post_user_id] => 14042 [last_post_username] => hist78 [last_thread_id] => 22909 [last_thread_title] => Foundry Monopoly in leading-edge Manufacturing: is it a real problem? [last_thread_prefix_id] => 0 [moderate_threads] => 0 [moderate_replies] => 0 [allow_posting] => 1 [count_messages] => 1 [find_new] => 1 [allow_index] => allow [index_criteria] => [field_cache] => [] [prefix_cache] => [] [prompt_cache] => [] [default_prefix_id] => 0 [default_sort_order] => last_post_date [default_sort_direction] => desc [list_date_limit_days] => 0 [require_prefix] => 0 [allowed_watch_notifications] => all [min_tags] => 0 [forum_type_id] => discussion [type_config] => {"allowed_thread_types":["poll"]} ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [Node] => XF\Entity\Node Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 49 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Node [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [title] => SemiWiki Main Forum ( Ask the Experts! ) [description] => Post your questions to the experts here! [node_name] => [node_type_id] => Forum [parent_node_id] => 1 [display_order] => 1 [display_in_list] => 1 [lft] => 2 [rgt] => 3 [depth] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [effective_style_id] => 0 [breadcrumb_data] => {"1":{"node_id":1,"title":"Main Category","depth":0,"lft":1,"node_name":null,"node_type_id":"Category","display_in_list":true}} [navigation_id] => [effective_navigation_id] => ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [17393] => ThemeHouse\XPress\XF\Entity\Thread Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 67 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Thread [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [thread_id] => 17393 [node_id] => 2 [title] => Intel cuts pay to support the dividend [reply_count] => 13 [view_count] => 4418 [user_id] => 38697 [username] => blueone [post_date] => 1675218660 [sticky] => 0 [discussion_state] => visible [discussion_open] => 1 [discussion_type] => discussion [first_post_id] => 58118 [first_post_reaction_score] => 1 [first_post_reactions] => {"3":1} [last_post_date] => 1748617366 [last_post_id] => 86853 [last_post_user_id] => 347598 [last_post_username] => Spreorke [prefix_id] => 0 [tags] => [] [custom_fields] => [] [vote_score] => 0 [vote_count] => 0 [type_data] => [] ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [User] => ThemeHouse\XLink\XF\Entity\User Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 64 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\User [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [user_id] => 38697 [username] => blueone [username_date] => 0 [username_date_visible] => 0 [email] => rob8633@hotmail.com [custom_title] => [language_id] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [timezone] => America/Denver [visible] => 0 [activity_visible] => 0 [user_group_id] => 2 [secondary_group_ids] => [display_style_group_id] => 2 [permission_combination_id] => 8 [message_count] => 1983 [question_solution_count] => 0 [conversations_unread] => 0 [register_date] => 1621824096 [last_activity] => 1748748345 [last_summary_email_date] => [trophy_points] => 113 [alerts_unviewed] => 1 [alerts_unread] => 1 [avatar_date] => 0 [avatar_width] => 0 [avatar_height] => 0 [avatar_highdpi] => 0 [gravatar] => [user_state] => valid [security_lock] => [is_moderator] => 0 [is_admin] => 0 [is_banned] => 0 [reaction_score] => 2387 [warning_points] => 0 [is_staff] => 0 [secret_key] => aGlUsVcP2cy-QllnjVLMCtpGT8e-_F_T [privacy_policy_accepted] => 1621824096 [terms_accepted] => 1621824096 [vote_score] => 0 ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [Forum] => XF\Entity\Forum Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 50 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Forum [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [discussion_count] => 7402 [message_count] => 51241 [last_post_id] => 86882 [last_post_date] => 1748748843 [last_post_user_id] => 14042 [last_post_username] => hist78 [last_thread_id] => 22909 [last_thread_title] => Foundry Monopoly in leading-edge Manufacturing: is it a real problem? [last_thread_prefix_id] => 0 [moderate_threads] => 0 [moderate_replies] => 0 [allow_posting] => 1 [count_messages] => 1 [find_new] => 1 [allow_index] => allow [index_criteria] => [field_cache] => [] [prefix_cache] => [] [prompt_cache] => [] [default_prefix_id] => 0 [default_sort_order] => last_post_date [default_sort_direction] => desc [list_date_limit_days] => 0 [require_prefix] => 0 [allowed_watch_notifications] => all [min_tags] => 0 [forum_type_id] => discussion [type_config] => {"allowed_thread_types":["poll"]} ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [Node] => XF\Entity\Node Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 49 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Node [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [title] => SemiWiki Main Forum ( Ask the Experts! ) [description] => Post your questions to the experts here! [node_name] => [node_type_id] => Forum [parent_node_id] => 1 [display_order] => 1 [display_in_list] => 1 [lft] => 2 [rgt] => 3 [depth] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [effective_style_id] => 0 [breadcrumb_data] => {"1":{"node_id":1,"title":"Main Category","depth":0,"lft":1,"node_name":null,"node_type_id":"Category","display_in_list":true}} [navigation_id] => [effective_navigation_id] => ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [22925] => ThemeHouse\XPress\XF\Entity\Thread Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 71 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Thread [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [thread_id] => 22925 [node_id] => 2 [title] => Hitachi Electron Microscope View of a 5nm FinFET [reply_count] => 3 [view_count] => 869 [user_id] => 5 [username] => Daniel Nenni [post_date] => 1748551792 [sticky] => 0 [discussion_state] => visible [discussion_open] => 1 [discussion_type] => discussion [first_post_id] => 86831 [first_post_reaction_score] => 4 [first_post_reactions] => {"1":2,"2":2,"4":1} [last_post_date] => 1748616332 [last_post_id] => 86852 [last_post_user_id] => 5185 [last_post_username] => Fred Chen [prefix_id] => 0 [tags] => [] [custom_fields] => [] [vote_score] => 0 [vote_count] => 0 [type_data] => [] ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [User] => ThemeHouse\XLink\XF\Entity\User Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 52 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\User [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [user_id] => 5 [username] => Daniel Nenni [username_date] => 0 [username_date_visible] => 0 [email] => dnenni@semiwiki.com [custom_title] => Admin [language_id] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [timezone] => America/Los_Angeles [visible] => 1 [activity_visible] => 1 [user_group_id] => 3 [secondary_group_ids] => 4,5,132 [display_style_group_id] => 3 [permission_combination_id] => 88 [message_count] => 13689 [question_solution_count] => 0 [conversations_unread] => 0 [register_date] => 1280720820 [last_activity] => 1748729203 [last_summary_email_date] => 1605968657 [trophy_points] => 113 [alerts_unviewed] => 99 [alerts_unread] => 99 [avatar_date] => 1663211649 [avatar_width] => 110 [avatar_height] => 107 [avatar_highdpi] => 0 [gravatar] => [user_state] => valid [security_lock] => [is_moderator] => 1 [is_admin] => 1 [is_banned] => 0 [reaction_score] => 6726 [warning_points] => 0 [is_staff] => 1 [secret_key] => 0HwyUVVHCwJotUUVEpvqAclfYJdGNPpw [privacy_policy_accepted] => 0 [terms_accepted] => 0 [vote_score] => 0 ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [Forum] => XF\Entity\Forum Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 50 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Forum [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [discussion_count] => 7402 [message_count] => 51241 [last_post_id] => 86882 [last_post_date] => 1748748843 [last_post_user_id] => 14042 [last_post_username] => hist78 [last_thread_id] => 22909 [last_thread_title] => Foundry Monopoly in leading-edge Manufacturing: is it a real problem? [last_thread_prefix_id] => 0 [moderate_threads] => 0 [moderate_replies] => 0 [allow_posting] => 1 [count_messages] => 1 [find_new] => 1 [allow_index] => allow [index_criteria] => [field_cache] => [] [prefix_cache] => [] [prompt_cache] => [] [default_prefix_id] => 0 [default_sort_order] => last_post_date [default_sort_direction] => desc [list_date_limit_days] => 0 [require_prefix] => 0 [allowed_watch_notifications] => all [min_tags] => 0 [forum_type_id] => discussion [type_config] => {"allowed_thread_types":["poll"]} ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [Node] => XF\Entity\Node Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 49 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Node [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [title] => SemiWiki Main Forum ( Ask the Experts! ) [description] => Post your questions to the experts here! [node_name] => [node_type_id] => Forum [parent_node_id] => 1 [display_order] => 1 [display_in_list] => 1 [lft] => 2 [rgt] => 3 [depth] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [effective_style_id] => 0 [breadcrumb_data] => {"1":{"node_id":1,"title":"Main Category","depth":0,"lft":1,"node_name":null,"node_type_id":"Category","display_in_list":true}} [navigation_id] => [effective_navigation_id] => ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [22930] => ThemeHouse\XPress\XF\Entity\Thread Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 75 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Thread [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [thread_id] => 22930 [node_id] => 2 [title] => Who will dominate quantum computing and at what levels? [reply_count] => 2 [view_count] => 562 [user_id] => 10499 [username] => Arthur Hanson [post_date] => 1748605917 [sticky] => 0 [discussion_state] => visible [discussion_open] => 1 [discussion_type] => discussion [first_post_id] => 86845 [first_post_reaction_score] => 0 [first_post_reactions] => [] [last_post_date] => 1748614611 [last_post_id] => 86849 [last_post_user_id] => 10499 [last_post_username] => Arthur Hanson [prefix_id] => 0 [tags] => [] [custom_fields] => [] [vote_score] => 0 [vote_count] => 0 [type_data] => [] ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [User] => ThemeHouse\XLink\XF\Entity\User Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 72 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\User [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [user_id] => 10499 [username] => Arthur Hanson [username_date] => 0 [username_date_visible] => 0 [email] => a-j-hanson@att.net [custom_title] => [language_id] => 1 [style_id] => 1 [timezone] => America/Los_Angeles [visible] => 1 [activity_visible] => 1 [user_group_id] => 2 [secondary_group_ids] => [display_style_group_id] => 2 [permission_combination_id] => 8 [message_count] => 3241 [question_solution_count] => 0 [conversations_unread] => 0 [register_date] => 1366028460 [last_activity] => 1748692371 [last_summary_email_date] => 1606051785 [trophy_points] => 83 [alerts_unviewed] => 3 [alerts_unread] => 3 [avatar_date] => 0 [avatar_width] => 0 [avatar_height] => 0 [avatar_highdpi] => 0 [gravatar] => [user_state] => valid [security_lock] => [is_moderator] => 0 [is_admin] => 0 [is_banned] => 0 [reaction_score] => 428 [warning_points] => 0 [is_staff] => 0 [secret_key] => ta_8_Pj20m6PDO6RnrGK-VnSP_vyhP_m [privacy_policy_accepted] => 0 [terms_accepted] => 0 [vote_score] => 0 ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [Forum] => XF\Entity\Forum Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 50 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Forum [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [discussion_count] => 7402 [message_count] => 51241 [last_post_id] => 86882 [last_post_date] => 1748748843 [last_post_user_id] => 14042 [last_post_username] => hist78 [last_thread_id] => 22909 [last_thread_title] => Foundry Monopoly in leading-edge Manufacturing: is it a real problem? [last_thread_prefix_id] => 0 [moderate_threads] => 0 [moderate_replies] => 0 [allow_posting] => 1 [count_messages] => 1 [find_new] => 1 [allow_index] => allow [index_criteria] => [field_cache] => [] [prefix_cache] => [] [prompt_cache] => [] [default_prefix_id] => 0 [default_sort_order] => last_post_date [default_sort_direction] => desc [list_date_limit_days] => 0 [require_prefix] => 0 [allowed_watch_notifications] => all [min_tags] => 0 [forum_type_id] => discussion [type_config] => {"allowed_thread_types":["poll"]} ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [Node] => XF\Entity\Node Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 49 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Node [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [title] => SemiWiki Main Forum ( Ask the Experts! ) [description] => Post your questions to the experts here! [node_name] => [node_type_id] => Forum [parent_node_id] => 1 [display_order] => 1 [display_in_list] => 1 [lft] => 2 [rgt] => 3 [depth] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [effective_style_id] => 0 [breadcrumb_data] => {"1":{"node_id":1,"title":"Main Category","depth":0,"lft":1,"node_name":null,"node_type_id":"Category","display_in_list":true}} [navigation_id] => [effective_navigation_id] => ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [22929] => ThemeHouse\XPress\XF\Entity\Thread Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 79 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Thread [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [thread_id] => 22929 [node_id] => 2 [title] => More Semicon Reality - Renesas abandons SiC plan [reply_count] => 1 [view_count] => 644 [user_id] => 20231 [username] => Barnsley [post_date] => 1748573795 [sticky] => 0 [discussion_state] => visible [discussion_open] => 1 [discussion_type] => discussion [first_post_id] => 86841 [first_post_reaction_score] => 1 [first_post_reactions] => {"1":1} [last_post_date] => 1748606747 [last_post_id] => 86846 [last_post_user_id] => 36448 [last_post_username] => Paul2 [prefix_id] => 0 [tags] => [] [custom_fields] => [] [vote_score] => 0 [vote_count] => 0 [type_data] => [] ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [User] => ThemeHouse\XLink\XF\Entity\User Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 76 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\User [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [user_id] => 20231 [username] => Barnsley [username_date] => 0 [username_date_visible] => 0 [email] => apickering72@gmail.com [custom_title] => [language_id] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [timezone] => Asia/Irkutsk [visible] => 1 [activity_visible] => 1 [user_group_id] => 2 [secondary_group_ids] => [display_style_group_id] => 2 [permission_combination_id] => 8 [message_count] => 1010 [question_solution_count] => 0 [conversations_unread] => 0 [register_date] => 1429440429 [last_activity] => 1748753199 [last_summary_email_date] => 1653315673 [trophy_points] => 83 [alerts_unviewed] => 27 [alerts_unread] => 27 [avatar_date] => 0 [avatar_width] => 0 [avatar_height] => 0 [avatar_highdpi] => 0 [gravatar] => [user_state] => valid [security_lock] => [is_moderator] => 0 [is_admin] => 0 [is_banned] => 0 [reaction_score] => 457 [warning_points] => 0 [is_staff] => 0 [secret_key] => iAnkz9GTDfivRmH1BOp6OTrgESJR57G8 [privacy_policy_accepted] => 0 [terms_accepted] => 0 [vote_score] => 0 ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [Forum] => XF\Entity\Forum Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 50 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Forum [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [discussion_count] => 7402 [message_count] => 51241 [last_post_id] => 86882 [last_post_date] => 1748748843 [last_post_user_id] => 14042 [last_post_username] => hist78 [last_thread_id] => 22909 [last_thread_title] => Foundry Monopoly in leading-edge Manufacturing: is it a real problem? [last_thread_prefix_id] => 0 [moderate_threads] => 0 [moderate_replies] => 0 [allow_posting] => 1 [count_messages] => 1 [find_new] => 1 [allow_index] => allow [index_criteria] => [field_cache] => [] [prefix_cache] => [] [prompt_cache] => [] [default_prefix_id] => 0 [default_sort_order] => last_post_date [default_sort_direction] => desc [list_date_limit_days] => 0 [require_prefix] => 0 [allowed_watch_notifications] => all [min_tags] => 0 [forum_type_id] => discussion [type_config] => {"allowed_thread_types":["poll"]} ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [Node] => XF\Entity\Node Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 49 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Node [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [title] => SemiWiki Main Forum ( Ask the Experts! ) [description] => Post your questions to the experts here! [node_name] => [node_type_id] => Forum [parent_node_id] => 1 [display_order] => 1 [display_in_list] => 1 [lft] => 2 [rgt] => 3 [depth] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [effective_style_id] => 0 [breadcrumb_data] => {"1":{"node_id":1,"title":"Main Category","depth":0,"lft":1,"node_name":null,"node_type_id":"Category","display_in_list":true}} [navigation_id] => [effective_navigation_id] => ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [22920] => ThemeHouse\XPress\XF\Entity\Thread Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 83 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Thread [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [thread_id] => 22920 [node_id] => 2 [title] => Earnings call transcript: NVIDIA beats Q1 2025 expectations [reply_count] => 3 [view_count] => 1426 [user_id] => 5 [username] => Daniel Nenni [post_date] => 1748476079 [sticky] => 0 [discussion_state] => visible [discussion_open] => 1 [discussion_type] => discussion [first_post_id] => 86780 [first_post_reaction_score] => 0 [first_post_reactions] => [] [last_post_date] => 1748553069 [last_post_id] => 86836 [last_post_user_id] => 5 [last_post_username] => Daniel Nenni [prefix_id] => 0 [tags] => [] [custom_fields] => [] [vote_score] => 0 [vote_count] => 0 [type_data] => [] ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [User] => ThemeHouse\XLink\XF\Entity\User Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 52 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\User [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [user_id] => 5 [username] => Daniel Nenni [username_date] => 0 [username_date_visible] => 0 [email] => dnenni@semiwiki.com [custom_title] => Admin [language_id] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [timezone] => America/Los_Angeles [visible] => 1 [activity_visible] => 1 [user_group_id] => 3 [secondary_group_ids] => 4,5,132 [display_style_group_id] => 3 [permission_combination_id] => 88 [message_count] => 13689 [question_solution_count] => 0 [conversations_unread] => 0 [register_date] => 1280720820 [last_activity] => 1748729203 [last_summary_email_date] => 1605968657 [trophy_points] => 113 [alerts_unviewed] => 99 [alerts_unread] => 99 [avatar_date] => 1663211649 [avatar_width] => 110 [avatar_height] => 107 [avatar_highdpi] => 0 [gravatar] => [user_state] => valid [security_lock] => [is_moderator] => 1 [is_admin] => 1 [is_banned] => 0 [reaction_score] => 6726 [warning_points] => 0 [is_staff] => 1 [secret_key] => 0HwyUVVHCwJotUUVEpvqAclfYJdGNPpw [privacy_policy_accepted] => 0 [terms_accepted] => 0 [vote_score] => 0 ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [Forum] => XF\Entity\Forum Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 50 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Forum [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [discussion_count] => 7402 [message_count] => 51241 [last_post_id] => 86882 [last_post_date] => 1748748843 [last_post_user_id] => 14042 [last_post_username] => hist78 [last_thread_id] => 22909 [last_thread_title] => Foundry Monopoly in leading-edge Manufacturing: is it a real problem? [last_thread_prefix_id] => 0 [moderate_threads] => 0 [moderate_replies] => 0 [allow_posting] => 1 [count_messages] => 1 [find_new] => 1 [allow_index] => allow [index_criteria] => [field_cache] => [] [prefix_cache] => [] [prompt_cache] => [] [default_prefix_id] => 0 [default_sort_order] => last_post_date [default_sort_direction] => desc [list_date_limit_days] => 0 [require_prefix] => 0 [allowed_watch_notifications] => all [min_tags] => 0 [forum_type_id] => discussion [type_config] => {"allowed_thread_types":["poll"]} ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [Node] => XF\Entity\Node Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 49 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Node [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [title] => SemiWiki Main Forum ( Ask the Experts! ) [description] => Post your questions to the experts here! [node_name] => [node_type_id] => Forum [parent_node_id] => 1 [display_order] => 1 [display_in_list] => 1 [lft] => 2 [rgt] => 3 [depth] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [effective_style_id] => 0 [breadcrumb_data] => {"1":{"node_id":1,"title":"Main Category","depth":0,"lft":1,"node_name":null,"node_type_id":"Category","display_in_list":true}} [navigation_id] => [effective_navigation_id] => ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [22882] => ThemeHouse\XPress\XF\Entity\Thread Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 87 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Thread [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [thread_id] => 22882 [node_id] => 2 [title] => Ukrainian Drones Target Russian Semiconductor Plant and Disrupt Internet Near Moscow [reply_count] => 18 [view_count] => 2021 [user_id] => 5 [username] => Daniel Nenni [post_date] => 1747872296 [sticky] => 0 [discussion_state] => visible [discussion_open] => 1 [discussion_type] => discussion [first_post_id] => 86551 [first_post_reaction_score] => 0 [first_post_reactions] => {"4":1} [last_post_date] => 1748537651 [last_post_id] => 86817 [last_post_user_id] => 5 [last_post_username] => Daniel Nenni [prefix_id] => 0 [tags] => [] [custom_fields] => [] [vote_score] => 0 [vote_count] => 0 [type_data] => [] ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [User] => ThemeHouse\XLink\XF\Entity\User Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 52 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\User [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [user_id] => 5 [username] => Daniel Nenni [username_date] => 0 [username_date_visible] => 0 [email] => dnenni@semiwiki.com [custom_title] => Admin [language_id] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [timezone] => America/Los_Angeles [visible] => 1 [activity_visible] => 1 [user_group_id] => 3 [secondary_group_ids] => 4,5,132 [display_style_group_id] => 3 [permission_combination_id] => 88 [message_count] => 13689 [question_solution_count] => 0 [conversations_unread] => 0 [register_date] => 1280720820 [last_activity] => 1748729203 [last_summary_email_date] => 1605968657 [trophy_points] => 113 [alerts_unviewed] => 99 [alerts_unread] => 99 [avatar_date] => 1663211649 [avatar_width] => 110 [avatar_height] => 107 [avatar_highdpi] => 0 [gravatar] => [user_state] => valid [security_lock] => [is_moderator] => 1 [is_admin] => 1 [is_banned] => 0 [reaction_score] => 6726 [warning_points] => 0 [is_staff] => 1 [secret_key] => 0HwyUVVHCwJotUUVEpvqAclfYJdGNPpw [privacy_policy_accepted] => 0 [terms_accepted] => 0 [vote_score] => 0 ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [Forum] => XF\Entity\Forum Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 50 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Forum [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [discussion_count] => 7402 [message_count] => 51241 [last_post_id] => 86882 [last_post_date] => 1748748843 [last_post_user_id] => 14042 [last_post_username] => hist78 [last_thread_id] => 22909 [last_thread_title] => Foundry Monopoly in leading-edge Manufacturing: is it a real problem? [last_thread_prefix_id] => 0 [moderate_threads] => 0 [moderate_replies] => 0 [allow_posting] => 1 [count_messages] => 1 [find_new] => 1 [allow_index] => allow [index_criteria] => [field_cache] => [] [prefix_cache] => [] [prompt_cache] => [] [default_prefix_id] => 0 [default_sort_order] => last_post_date [default_sort_direction] => desc [list_date_limit_days] => 0 [require_prefix] => 0 [allowed_watch_notifications] => all [min_tags] => 0 [forum_type_id] => discussion [type_config] => {"allowed_thread_types":["poll"]} ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [Node] => XF\Entity\Node Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 49 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Node [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [title] => SemiWiki Main Forum ( Ask the Experts! ) [description] => Post your questions to the experts here! [node_name] => [node_type_id] => Forum [parent_node_id] => 1 [display_order] => 1 [display_in_list] => 1 [lft] => 2 [rgt] => 3 [depth] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [effective_style_id] => 0 [breadcrumb_data] => {"1":{"node_id":1,"title":"Main Category","depth":0,"lft":1,"node_name":null,"node_type_id":"Category","display_in_list":true}} [navigation_id] => [effective_navigation_id] => ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [22911] => ThemeHouse\XPress\XF\Entity\Thread Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 91 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Thread [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [thread_id] => 22911 [node_id] => 2 [title] => UMC Shrugs Off Middle East Expansion; Calls Intel’s 12nm Project a Must-Win [reply_count] => 12 [view_count] => 1097 [user_id] => 90182 [username] => siliconbruh999 [post_date] => 1748445652 [sticky] => 0 [discussion_state] => visible [discussion_open] => 1 [discussion_type] => discussion [first_post_id] => 86753 [first_post_reaction_score] => 1 [first_post_reactions] => {"1":1} [last_post_date] => 1748537337 [last_post_id] => 86816 [last_post_user_id] => 333811 [last_post_username] => tedc [prefix_id] => 0 [tags] => [] [custom_fields] => [] [vote_score] => 0 [vote_count] => 0 [type_data] => [] ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [User] => ThemeHouse\XLink\XF\Entity\User Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 88 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\User [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [user_id] => 90182 [username] => siliconbruh999 [username_date] => 0 [username_date_visible] => 0 [email] => mameba3809@xtrempro.com [custom_title] => [language_id] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [timezone] => Europe/Moscow [visible] => 1 [activity_visible] => 1 [user_group_id] => 2 [secondary_group_ids] => [display_style_group_id] => 2 [permission_combination_id] => 8 [message_count] => 955 [question_solution_count] => 0 [conversations_unread] => 0 [register_date] => 1639920123 [last_activity] => 1748750231 [last_summary_email_date] => [trophy_points] => 93 [alerts_unviewed] => 1 [alerts_unread] => 4 [avatar_date] => 0 [avatar_width] => 0 [avatar_height] => 0 [avatar_highdpi] => 0 [gravatar] => [user_state] => valid [security_lock] => [is_moderator] => 0 [is_admin] => 0 [is_banned] => 0 [reaction_score] => 985 [warning_points] => 0 [is_staff] => 0 [secret_key] => P2aaLJmGIrhZpcNz1Y4-qcFwSWmaD8NE [privacy_policy_accepted] => 1639920123 [terms_accepted] => 1639920123 [vote_score] => 0 ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [Forum] => XF\Entity\Forum Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 50 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Forum [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [discussion_count] => 7402 [message_count] => 51241 [last_post_id] => 86882 [last_post_date] => 1748748843 [last_post_user_id] => 14042 [last_post_username] => hist78 [last_thread_id] => 22909 [last_thread_title] => Foundry Monopoly in leading-edge Manufacturing: is it a real problem? [last_thread_prefix_id] => 0 [moderate_threads] => 0 [moderate_replies] => 0 [allow_posting] => 1 [count_messages] => 1 [find_new] => 1 [allow_index] => allow [index_criteria] => [field_cache] => [] [prefix_cache] => [] [prompt_cache] => [] [default_prefix_id] => 0 [default_sort_order] => last_post_date [default_sort_direction] => desc [list_date_limit_days] => 0 [require_prefix] => 0 [allowed_watch_notifications] => all [min_tags] => 0 [forum_type_id] => discussion [type_config] => {"allowed_thread_types":["poll"]} ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [Node] => XF\Entity\Node Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 49 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Node [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [title] => SemiWiki Main Forum ( Ask the Experts! ) [description] => Post your questions to the experts here! [node_name] => [node_type_id] => Forum [parent_node_id] => 1 [display_order] => 1 [display_in_list] => 1 [lft] => 2 [rgt] => 3 [depth] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [effective_style_id] => 0 [breadcrumb_data] => {"1":{"node_id":1,"title":"Main Category","depth":0,"lft":1,"node_name":null,"node_type_id":"Category","display_in_list":true}} [navigation_id] => [effective_navigation_id] => ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [22878] => ThemeHouse\XPress\XF\Entity\Thread Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 95 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Thread [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [thread_id] => 22878 [node_id] => 2 [title] => Wolfspeed Prepares to File for Bankruptcy Within Weeks [reply_count] => 12 [view_count] => 2159 [user_id] => 29441 [username] => tonyget [post_date] => 1747823196 [sticky] => 0 [discussion_state] => visible [discussion_open] => 1 [discussion_type] => discussion [first_post_id] => 86528 [first_post_reaction_score] => 0 [first_post_reactions] => {"4":2,"5":1} [last_post_date] => 1748535609 [last_post_id] => 86815 [last_post_user_id] => 5 [last_post_username] => Daniel Nenni [prefix_id] => 0 [tags] => [] [custom_fields] => [] [vote_score] => 0 [vote_count] => 0 [type_data] => [] ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [User] => ThemeHouse\XLink\XF\Entity\User Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 92 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\User [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [user_id] => 29441 [username] => tonyget [username_date] => 0 [username_date_visible] => 0 [email] => tonygect@gmail.com [custom_title] => [language_id] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [timezone] => America/Los_Angeles [visible] => 1 [activity_visible] => 1 [user_group_id] => 2 [secondary_group_ids] => [display_style_group_id] => 2 [permission_combination_id] => 8 [message_count] => 477 [question_solution_count] => 0 [conversations_unread] => 0 [register_date] => 1530379703 [last_activity] => 1748670420 [last_summary_email_date] => [trophy_points] => 63 [alerts_unviewed] => 0 [alerts_unread] => 0 [avatar_date] => 0 [avatar_width] => 0 [avatar_height] => 0 [avatar_highdpi] => 0 [gravatar] => [user_state] => valid [security_lock] => [is_moderator] => 0 [is_admin] => 0 [is_banned] => 0 [reaction_score] => 294 [warning_points] => 0 [is_staff] => 0 [secret_key] => p8Xu8RMcYNG2Mp-_wc8Za9aU-kUYGMwP [privacy_policy_accepted] => 0 [terms_accepted] => 0 [vote_score] => 0 ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [Forum] => XF\Entity\Forum Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 50 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Forum [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [discussion_count] => 7402 [message_count] => 51241 [last_post_id] => 86882 [last_post_date] => 1748748843 [last_post_user_id] => 14042 [last_post_username] => hist78 [last_thread_id] => 22909 [last_thread_title] => Foundry Monopoly in leading-edge Manufacturing: is it a real problem? [last_thread_prefix_id] => 0 [moderate_threads] => 0 [moderate_replies] => 0 [allow_posting] => 1 [count_messages] => 1 [find_new] => 1 [allow_index] => allow [index_criteria] => [field_cache] => [] [prefix_cache] => [] [prompt_cache] => [] [default_prefix_id] => 0 [default_sort_order] => last_post_date [default_sort_direction] => desc [list_date_limit_days] => 0 [require_prefix] => 0 [allowed_watch_notifications] => all [min_tags] => 0 [forum_type_id] => discussion [type_config] => {"allowed_thread_types":["poll"]} ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [Node] => XF\Entity\Node Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 49 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Node [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [title] => SemiWiki Main Forum ( Ask the Experts! ) [description] => Post your questions to the experts here! [node_name] => [node_type_id] => Forum [parent_node_id] => 1 [display_order] => 1 [display_in_list] => 1 [lft] => 2 [rgt] => 3 [depth] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [effective_style_id] => 0 [breadcrumb_data] => {"1":{"node_id":1,"title":"Main Category","depth":0,"lft":1,"node_name":null,"node_type_id":"Category","display_in_list":true}} [navigation_id] => [effective_navigation_id] => ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [22891] => ThemeHouse\XPress\XF\Entity\Thread Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 99 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Thread [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [thread_id] => 22891 [node_id] => 2 [title] => US doesn't welcome foreign talents as Trump bars Harvard from enrolling foreign students anymore [reply_count] => 28 [view_count] => 3909 [user_id] => 29441 [username] => tonyget [post_date] => 1747997413 [sticky] => 0 [discussion_state] => visible [discussion_open] => 1 [discussion_type] => discussion [first_post_id] => 86627 [first_post_reaction_score] => 0 [first_post_reactions] => [] [last_post_date] => 1748524446 [last_post_id] => 86812 [last_post_user_id] => 38697 [last_post_username] => blueone [prefix_id] => 0 [tags] => [] [custom_fields] => [] [vote_score] => 0 [vote_count] => 0 [type_data] => [] ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [User] => ThemeHouse\XLink\XF\Entity\User Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 92 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\User [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [user_id] => 29441 [username] => tonyget [username_date] => 0 [username_date_visible] => 0 [email] => tonygect@gmail.com [custom_title] => [language_id] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [timezone] => America/Los_Angeles [visible] => 1 [activity_visible] => 1 [user_group_id] => 2 [secondary_group_ids] => [display_style_group_id] => 2 [permission_combination_id] => 8 [message_count] => 477 [question_solution_count] => 0 [conversations_unread] => 0 [register_date] => 1530379703 [last_activity] => 1748670420 [last_summary_email_date] => [trophy_points] => 63 [alerts_unviewed] => 0 [alerts_unread] => 0 [avatar_date] => 0 [avatar_width] => 0 [avatar_height] => 0 [avatar_highdpi] => 0 [gravatar] => [user_state] => valid [security_lock] => [is_moderator] => 0 [is_admin] => 0 [is_banned] => 0 [reaction_score] => 294 [warning_points] => 0 [is_staff] => 0 [secret_key] => p8Xu8RMcYNG2Mp-_wc8Za9aU-kUYGMwP [privacy_policy_accepted] => 0 [terms_accepted] => 0 [vote_score] => 0 ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [Forum] => XF\Entity\Forum Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 50 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Forum [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [discussion_count] => 7402 [message_count] => 51241 [last_post_id] => 86882 [last_post_date] => 1748748843 [last_post_user_id] => 14042 [last_post_username] => hist78 [last_thread_id] => 22909 [last_thread_title] => Foundry Monopoly in leading-edge Manufacturing: is it a real problem? [last_thread_prefix_id] => 0 [moderate_threads] => 0 [moderate_replies] => 0 [allow_posting] => 1 [count_messages] => 1 [find_new] => 1 [allow_index] => allow [index_criteria] => [field_cache] => [] [prefix_cache] => [] [prompt_cache] => [] [default_prefix_id] => 0 [default_sort_order] => last_post_date [default_sort_direction] => desc [list_date_limit_days] => 0 [require_prefix] => 0 [allowed_watch_notifications] => all [min_tags] => 0 [forum_type_id] => discussion [type_config] => {"allowed_thread_types":["poll"]} ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [Node] => XF\Entity\Node Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 49 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Node [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [title] => SemiWiki Main Forum ( Ask the Experts! ) [description] => Post your questions to the experts here! [node_name] => [node_type_id] => Forum [parent_node_id] => 1 [display_order] => 1 [display_in_list] => 1 [lft] => 2 [rgt] => 3 [depth] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [effective_style_id] => 0 [breadcrumb_data] => {"1":{"node_id":1,"title":"Main Category","depth":0,"lft":1,"node_name":null,"node_type_id":"Category","display_in_list":true}} [navigation_id] => [effective_navigation_id] => ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [22924] => ThemeHouse\XPress\XF\Entity\Thread Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 103 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Thread [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [thread_id] => 22924 [node_id] => 2 [title] => The Other Side of Semicon - Wafer supplier Soitec withdraws mid-term, year-ahead guidance, changes CFO [reply_count] => 0 [view_count] => 352 [user_id] => 20231 [username] => Barnsley [post_date] => 1748505020 [sticky] => 0 [discussion_state] => visible [discussion_open] => 1 [discussion_type] => discussion [first_post_id] => 86801 [first_post_reaction_score] => 0 [first_post_reactions] => [] [last_post_date] => 1748505020 [last_post_id] => 86801 [last_post_user_id] => 20231 [last_post_username] => Barnsley [prefix_id] => 0 [tags] => [] [custom_fields] => [] [vote_score] => 0 [vote_count] => 0 [type_data] => [] ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [User] => ThemeHouse\XLink\XF\Entity\User Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 76 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\User [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [user_id] => 20231 [username] => Barnsley [username_date] => 0 [username_date_visible] => 0 [email] => apickering72@gmail.com [custom_title] => [language_id] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [timezone] => Asia/Irkutsk [visible] => 1 [activity_visible] => 1 [user_group_id] => 2 [secondary_group_ids] => [display_style_group_id] => 2 [permission_combination_id] => 8 [message_count] => 1010 [question_solution_count] => 0 [conversations_unread] => 0 [register_date] => 1429440429 [last_activity] => 1748753199 [last_summary_email_date] => 1653315673 [trophy_points] => 83 [alerts_unviewed] => 27 [alerts_unread] => 27 [avatar_date] => 0 [avatar_width] => 0 [avatar_height] => 0 [avatar_highdpi] => 0 [gravatar] => [user_state] => valid [security_lock] => [is_moderator] => 0 [is_admin] => 0 [is_banned] => 0 [reaction_score] => 457 [warning_points] => 0 [is_staff] => 0 [secret_key] => iAnkz9GTDfivRmH1BOp6OTrgESJR57G8 [privacy_policy_accepted] => 0 [terms_accepted] => 0 [vote_score] => 0 ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [Forum] => XF\Entity\Forum Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 50 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Forum [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [discussion_count] => 7402 [message_count] => 51241 [last_post_id] => 86882 [last_post_date] => 1748748843 [last_post_user_id] => 14042 [last_post_username] => hist78 [last_thread_id] => 22909 [last_thread_title] => Foundry Monopoly in leading-edge Manufacturing: is it a real problem? [last_thread_prefix_id] => 0 [moderate_threads] => 0 [moderate_replies] => 0 [allow_posting] => 1 [count_messages] => 1 [find_new] => 1 [allow_index] => allow [index_criteria] => [field_cache] => [] [prefix_cache] => [] [prompt_cache] => [] [default_prefix_id] => 0 [default_sort_order] => last_post_date [default_sort_direction] => desc [list_date_limit_days] => 0 [require_prefix] => 0 [allowed_watch_notifications] => all [min_tags] => 0 [forum_type_id] => discussion [type_config] => {"allowed_thread_types":["poll"]} ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [Node] => XF\Entity\Node Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 49 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Node [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [title] => SemiWiki Main Forum ( Ask the Experts! ) [description] => Post your questions to the experts here! [node_name] => [node_type_id] => Forum [parent_node_id] => 1 [display_order] => 1 [display_in_list] => 1 [lft] => 2 [rgt] => 3 [depth] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [effective_style_id] => 0 [breadcrumb_data] => {"1":{"node_id":1,"title":"Main Category","depth":0,"lft":1,"node_name":null,"node_type_id":"Category","display_in_list":true}} [navigation_id] => [effective_navigation_id] => ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [22902] => ThemeHouse\XPress\XF\Entity\Thread Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 107 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Thread [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [thread_id] => 22902 [node_id] => 2 [title] => Intel needs external foundry customers to make 14A process node pay off [reply_count] => 10 [view_count] => 2055 [user_id] => 5185 [username] => Fred Chen [post_date] => 1748263465 [sticky] => 0 [discussion_state] => visible [discussion_open] => 1 [discussion_type] => discussion [first_post_id] => 86693 [first_post_reaction_score] => 0 [first_post_reactions] => [] [last_post_date] => 1748492804 [last_post_id] => 86796 [last_post_user_id] => 5 [last_post_username] => Daniel Nenni [prefix_id] => 0 [tags] => [] [custom_fields] => [] [vote_score] => 0 [vote_count] => 0 [type_data] => [] ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [User] => ThemeHouse\XLink\XF\Entity\User Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 104 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\User [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [user_id] => 5185 [username] => Fred Chen [username_date] => 0 [username_date_visible] => 0 [email] => chen.t.fred@gmail.com [custom_title] => [language_id] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [timezone] => America/Los_Angeles [visible] => 1 [activity_visible] => 1 [user_group_id] => 4 [secondary_group_ids] => [display_style_group_id] => 4 [permission_combination_id] => 92 [message_count] => 2169 [question_solution_count] => 0 [conversations_unread] => 0 [register_date] => 1333032401 [last_activity] => 1748624779 [last_summary_email_date] => 1605940563 [trophy_points] => 113 [alerts_unviewed] => 1 [alerts_unread] => 1 [avatar_date] => 0 [avatar_width] => 0 [avatar_height] => 0 [avatar_highdpi] => 0 [gravatar] => [user_state] => valid [security_lock] => [is_moderator] => 0 [is_admin] => 0 [is_banned] => 0 [reaction_score] => 1316 [warning_points] => 0 [is_staff] => 0 [secret_key] => 5m-bZq0HRSi9VA-96QONHJeevdQas5S8 [privacy_policy_accepted] => 0 [terms_accepted] => 0 [vote_score] => 0 ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [Forum] => XF\Entity\Forum Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 50 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Forum [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [discussion_count] => 7402 [message_count] => 51241 [last_post_id] => 86882 [last_post_date] => 1748748843 [last_post_user_id] => 14042 [last_post_username] => hist78 [last_thread_id] => 22909 [last_thread_title] => Foundry Monopoly in leading-edge Manufacturing: is it a real problem? [last_thread_prefix_id] => 0 [moderate_threads] => 0 [moderate_replies] => 0 [allow_posting] => 1 [count_messages] => 1 [find_new] => 1 [allow_index] => allow [index_criteria] => [field_cache] => [] [prefix_cache] => [] [prompt_cache] => [] [default_prefix_id] => 0 [default_sort_order] => last_post_date [default_sort_direction] => desc [list_date_limit_days] => 0 [require_prefix] => 0 [allowed_watch_notifications] => all [min_tags] => 0 [forum_type_id] => discussion [type_config] => {"allowed_thread_types":["poll"]} ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [Node] => XF\Entity\Node Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 49 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Node [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [title] => SemiWiki Main Forum ( Ask the Experts! ) [description] => Post your questions to the experts here! [node_name] => [node_type_id] => Forum [parent_node_id] => 1 [display_order] => 1 [display_in_list] => 1 [lft] => 2 [rgt] => 3 [depth] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [effective_style_id] => 0 [breadcrumb_data] => {"1":{"node_id":1,"title":"Main Category","depth":0,"lft":1,"node_name":null,"node_type_id":"Category","display_in_list":true}} [navigation_id] => [effective_navigation_id] => ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [22919] => ThemeHouse\XPress\XF\Entity\Thread Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 111 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Thread [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [thread_id] => 22919 [node_id] => 2 [title] => AMD Acquires Silicon Photonics Startup Enosemi In AI Systems Push [reply_count] => 0 [view_count] => 399 [user_id] => 5 [username] => Daniel Nenni [post_date] => 1748475323 [sticky] => 0 [discussion_state] => visible [discussion_open] => 1 [discussion_type] => discussion [first_post_id] => 86779 [first_post_reaction_score] => 0 [first_post_reactions] => [] [last_post_date] => 1748475323 [last_post_id] => 86779 [last_post_user_id] => 5 [last_post_username] => Daniel Nenni [prefix_id] => 0 [tags] => [] [custom_fields] => [] [vote_score] => 0 [vote_count] => 0 [type_data] => [] ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [User] => ThemeHouse\XLink\XF\Entity\User Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 52 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\User [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [user_id] => 5 [username] => Daniel Nenni [username_date] => 0 [username_date_visible] => 0 [email] => dnenni@semiwiki.com [custom_title] => Admin [language_id] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [timezone] => America/Los_Angeles [visible] => 1 [activity_visible] => 1 [user_group_id] => 3 [secondary_group_ids] => 4,5,132 [display_style_group_id] => 3 [permission_combination_id] => 88 [message_count] => 13689 [question_solution_count] => 0 [conversations_unread] => 0 [register_date] => 1280720820 [last_activity] => 1748729203 [last_summary_email_date] => 1605968657 [trophy_points] => 113 [alerts_unviewed] => 99 [alerts_unread] => 99 [avatar_date] => 1663211649 [avatar_width] => 110 [avatar_height] => 107 [avatar_highdpi] => 0 [gravatar] => [user_state] => valid [security_lock] => [is_moderator] => 1 [is_admin] => 1 [is_banned] => 0 [reaction_score] => 6726 [warning_points] => 0 [is_staff] => 1 [secret_key] => 0HwyUVVHCwJotUUVEpvqAclfYJdGNPpw [privacy_policy_accepted] => 0 [terms_accepted] => 0 [vote_score] => 0 ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [Forum] => XF\Entity\Forum Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 50 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Forum [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [discussion_count] => 7402 [message_count] => 51241 [last_post_id] => 86882 [last_post_date] => 1748748843 [last_post_user_id] => 14042 [last_post_username] => hist78 [last_thread_id] => 22909 [last_thread_title] => Foundry Monopoly in leading-edge Manufacturing: is it a real problem? [last_thread_prefix_id] => 0 [moderate_threads] => 0 [moderate_replies] => 0 [allow_posting] => 1 [count_messages] => 1 [find_new] => 1 [allow_index] => allow [index_criteria] => [field_cache] => [] [prefix_cache] => [] [prompt_cache] => [] [default_prefix_id] => 0 [default_sort_order] => last_post_date [default_sort_direction] => desc [list_date_limit_days] => 0 [require_prefix] => 0 [allowed_watch_notifications] => all [min_tags] => 0 [forum_type_id] => discussion [type_config] => {"allowed_thread_types":["poll"]} ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [Node] => XF\Entity\Node Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 49 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Node [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [title] => SemiWiki Main Forum ( Ask the Experts! ) [description] => Post your questions to the experts here! [node_name] => [node_type_id] => Forum [parent_node_id] => 1 [display_order] => 1 [display_in_list] => 1 [lft] => 2 [rgt] => 3 [depth] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [effective_style_id] => 0 [breadcrumb_data] => {"1":{"node_id":1,"title":"Main Category","depth":0,"lft":1,"node_name":null,"node_type_id":"Category","display_in_list":true}} [navigation_id] => [effective_navigation_id] => ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [22912] => ThemeHouse\XPress\XF\Entity\Thread Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 115 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Thread [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [thread_id] => 22912 [node_id] => 2 [title] => Lip-Bu Tan: A Journey of Calculated Risks and Entrepreneurial Success | TiEcon 2025 [reply_count] => 1 [view_count] => 506 [user_id] => 5 [username] => Daniel Nenni [post_date] => 1748458137 [sticky] => 0 [discussion_state] => visible [discussion_open] => 1 [discussion_type] => discussion [first_post_id] => 86764 [first_post_reaction_score] => 0 [first_post_reactions] => [] [last_post_date] => 1748467732 [last_post_id] => 86776 [last_post_user_id] => 5 [last_post_username] => Daniel Nenni [prefix_id] => 0 [tags] => [] [custom_fields] => [] [vote_score] => 0 [vote_count] => 0 [type_data] => [] ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [User] => ThemeHouse\XLink\XF\Entity\User Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 52 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\User [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [user_id] => 5 [username] => Daniel Nenni [username_date] => 0 [username_date_visible] => 0 [email] => dnenni@semiwiki.com [custom_title] => Admin [language_id] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [timezone] => America/Los_Angeles [visible] => 1 [activity_visible] => 1 [user_group_id] => 3 [secondary_group_ids] => 4,5,132 [display_style_group_id] => 3 [permission_combination_id] => 88 [message_count] => 13689 [question_solution_count] => 0 [conversations_unread] => 0 [register_date] => 1280720820 [last_activity] => 1748729203 [last_summary_email_date] => 1605968657 [trophy_points] => 113 [alerts_unviewed] => 99 [alerts_unread] => 99 [avatar_date] => 1663211649 [avatar_width] => 110 [avatar_height] => 107 [avatar_highdpi] => 0 [gravatar] => [user_state] => valid [security_lock] => [is_moderator] => 1 [is_admin] => 1 [is_banned] => 0 [reaction_score] => 6726 [warning_points] => 0 [is_staff] => 1 [secret_key] => 0HwyUVVHCwJotUUVEpvqAclfYJdGNPpw [privacy_policy_accepted] => 0 [terms_accepted] => 0 [vote_score] => 0 ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [Forum] => XF\Entity\Forum Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 50 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Forum [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [discussion_count] => 7402 [message_count] => 51241 [last_post_id] => 86882 [last_post_date] => 1748748843 [last_post_user_id] => 14042 [last_post_username] => hist78 [last_thread_id] => 22909 [last_thread_title] => Foundry Monopoly in leading-edge Manufacturing: is it a real problem? [last_thread_prefix_id] => 0 [moderate_threads] => 0 [moderate_replies] => 0 [allow_posting] => 1 [count_messages] => 1 [find_new] => 1 [allow_index] => allow [index_criteria] => [field_cache] => [] [prefix_cache] => [] [prompt_cache] => [] [default_prefix_id] => 0 [default_sort_order] => last_post_date [default_sort_direction] => desc [list_date_limit_days] => 0 [require_prefix] => 0 [allowed_watch_notifications] => all [min_tags] => 0 [forum_type_id] => discussion [type_config] => {"allowed_thread_types":["poll"]} ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [Node] => XF\Entity\Node Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 49 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Node [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [title] => SemiWiki Main Forum ( Ask the Experts! ) [description] => Post your questions to the experts here! [node_name] => [node_type_id] => Forum [parent_node_id] => 1 [display_order] => 1 [display_in_list] => 1 [lft] => 2 [rgt] => 3 [depth] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [effective_style_id] => 0 [breadcrumb_data] => {"1":{"node_id":1,"title":"Main Category","depth":0,"lft":1,"node_name":null,"node_type_id":"Category","display_in_list":true}} [navigation_id] => [effective_navigation_id] => ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [22888] => ThemeHouse\XPress\XF\Entity\Thread Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 119 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Thread [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [thread_id] => 22888 [node_id] => 2 [title] => Xiaomi’s first flagship phone chip is a genuine Snapdragon 8 Elite rival [reply_count] => 15 [view_count] => 1991 [user_id] => 36640 [username] => soAsian [post_date] => 1747932603 [sticky] => 0 [discussion_state] => visible [discussion_open] => 1 [discussion_type] => discussion [first_post_id] => 86600 [first_post_reaction_score] => 0 [first_post_reactions] => [] [last_post_date] => 1748466278 [last_post_id] => 86774 [last_post_user_id] => 36448 [last_post_username] => Paul2 [prefix_id] => 0 [tags] => [] [custom_fields] => [] [vote_score] => 0 [vote_count] => 0 [type_data] => [] ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [User] => ThemeHouse\XLink\XF\Entity\User Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 116 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\User [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [user_id] => 36640 [username] => soAsian [username_date] => 0 [username_date_visible] => 0 [email] => jackmtsai@gmail.com [custom_title] => [language_id] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [timezone] => America/Chicago [visible] => 1 [activity_visible] => 1 [user_group_id] => 2 [secondary_group_ids] => [display_style_group_id] => 2 [permission_combination_id] => 8 [message_count] => 301 [question_solution_count] => 0 [conversations_unread] => 0 [register_date] => 1608139716 [last_activity] => 1748748005 [last_summary_email_date] => 1719670845 [trophy_points] => 43 [alerts_unviewed] => 0 [alerts_unread] => 0 [avatar_date] => 0 [avatar_width] => 0 [avatar_height] => 0 [avatar_highdpi] => 0 [gravatar] => [user_state] => valid [security_lock] => [is_moderator] => 0 [is_admin] => 0 [is_banned] => 0 [reaction_score] => 219 [warning_points] => 0 [is_staff] => 0 [secret_key] => 2oKeCTFkGUpMro5tcmj7WaY9HksB13Kw [privacy_policy_accepted] => 1608139716 [terms_accepted] => 1608139716 [vote_score] => 0 ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [Forum] => XF\Entity\Forum Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 50 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Forum [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [discussion_count] => 7402 [message_count] => 51241 [last_post_id] => 86882 [last_post_date] => 1748748843 [last_post_user_id] => 14042 [last_post_username] => hist78 [last_thread_id] => 22909 [last_thread_title] => Foundry Monopoly in leading-edge Manufacturing: is it a real problem? [last_thread_prefix_id] => 0 [moderate_threads] => 0 [moderate_replies] => 0 [allow_posting] => 1 [count_messages] => 1 [find_new] => 1 [allow_index] => allow [index_criteria] => [field_cache] => [] [prefix_cache] => [] [prompt_cache] => [] [default_prefix_id] => 0 [default_sort_order] => last_post_date [default_sort_direction] => desc [list_date_limit_days] => 0 [require_prefix] => 0 [allowed_watch_notifications] => all [min_tags] => 0 [forum_type_id] => discussion [type_config] => {"allowed_thread_types":["poll"]} ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [Node] => XF\Entity\Node Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 49 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Node [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [title] => SemiWiki Main Forum ( Ask the Experts! ) [description] => Post your questions to the experts here! [node_name] => [node_type_id] => Forum [parent_node_id] => 1 [display_order] => 1 [display_in_list] => 1 [lft] => 2 [rgt] => 3 [depth] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [effective_style_id] => 0 [breadcrumb_data] => {"1":{"node_id":1,"title":"Main Category","depth":0,"lft":1,"node_name":null,"node_type_id":"Category","display_in_list":true}} [navigation_id] => [effective_navigation_id] => ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [22903] => ThemeHouse\XPress\XF\Entity\Thread Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 123 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Thread [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [thread_id] => 22903 [node_id] => 2 [title] => Nvidia CEO calls Trump re-industrialisation policies 'visionary' [reply_count] => 15 [view_count] => 1382 [user_id] => 5 [username] => Daniel Nenni [post_date] => 1748283266 [sticky] => 0 [discussion_state] => visible [discussion_open] => 1 [discussion_type] => discussion [first_post_id] => 86698 [first_post_reaction_score] => 1 [first_post_reactions] => {"1":1} [last_post_date] => 1748439259 [last_post_id] => 86743 [last_post_user_id] => 36448 [last_post_username] => Paul2 [prefix_id] => 0 [tags] => [] [custom_fields] => [] [vote_score] => 0 [vote_count] => 0 [type_data] => [] ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [User] => ThemeHouse\XLink\XF\Entity\User Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 52 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\User [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [user_id] => 5 [username] => Daniel Nenni [username_date] => 0 [username_date_visible] => 0 [email] => dnenni@semiwiki.com [custom_title] => Admin [language_id] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [timezone] => America/Los_Angeles [visible] => 1 [activity_visible] => 1 [user_group_id] => 3 [secondary_group_ids] => 4,5,132 [display_style_group_id] => 3 [permission_combination_id] => 88 [message_count] => 13689 [question_solution_count] => 0 [conversations_unread] => 0 [register_date] => 1280720820 [last_activity] => 1748729203 [last_summary_email_date] => 1605968657 [trophy_points] => 113 [alerts_unviewed] => 99 [alerts_unread] => 99 [avatar_date] => 1663211649 [avatar_width] => 110 [avatar_height] => 107 [avatar_highdpi] => 0 [gravatar] => [user_state] => valid [security_lock] => [is_moderator] => 1 [is_admin] => 1 [is_banned] => 0 [reaction_score] => 6726 [warning_points] => 0 [is_staff] => 1 [secret_key] => 0HwyUVVHCwJotUUVEpvqAclfYJdGNPpw [privacy_policy_accepted] => 0 [terms_accepted] => 0 [vote_score] => 0 ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [Forum] => XF\Entity\Forum Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 50 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Forum [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [discussion_count] => 7402 [message_count] => 51241 [last_post_id] => 86882 [last_post_date] => 1748748843 [last_post_user_id] => 14042 [last_post_username] => hist78 [last_thread_id] => 22909 [last_thread_title] => Foundry Monopoly in leading-edge Manufacturing: is it a real problem? [last_thread_prefix_id] => 0 [moderate_threads] => 0 [moderate_replies] => 0 [allow_posting] => 1 [count_messages] => 1 [find_new] => 1 [allow_index] => allow [index_criteria] => [field_cache] => [] [prefix_cache] => [] [prompt_cache] => [] [default_prefix_id] => 0 [default_sort_order] => last_post_date [default_sort_direction] => desc [list_date_limit_days] => 0 [require_prefix] => 0 [allowed_watch_notifications] => all [min_tags] => 0 [forum_type_id] => discussion [type_config] => {"allowed_thread_types":["poll"]} ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [Node] => XF\Entity\Node Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 49 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Node [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [title] => SemiWiki Main Forum ( Ask the Experts! ) [description] => Post your questions to the experts here! [node_name] => [node_type_id] => Forum [parent_node_id] => 1 [display_order] => 1 [display_in_list] => 1 [lft] => 2 [rgt] => 3 [depth] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [effective_style_id] => 0 [breadcrumb_data] => {"1":{"node_id":1,"title":"Main Category","depth":0,"lft":1,"node_name":null,"node_type_id":"Category","display_in_list":true}} [navigation_id] => [effective_navigation_id] => ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [22908] => ThemeHouse\XPress\XF\Entity\Thread Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 127 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Thread [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [thread_id] => 22908 [node_id] => 2 [title] => Taiwan's TSMC to open semiconductor design centre in Munich [reply_count] => 3 [view_count] => 644 [user_id] => 5 [username] => Daniel Nenni [post_date] => 1748363161 [sticky] => 0 [discussion_state] => visible [discussion_open] => 1 [discussion_type] => discussion [first_post_id] => 86725 [first_post_reaction_score] => 0 [first_post_reactions] => [] [last_post_date] => 1748429485 [last_post_id] => 86740 [last_post_user_id] => 36448 [last_post_username] => Paul2 [prefix_id] => 0 [tags] => [] [custom_fields] => [] [vote_score] => 0 [vote_count] => 0 [type_data] => [] ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [User] => ThemeHouse\XLink\XF\Entity\User Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 52 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\User [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [user_id] => 5 [username] => Daniel Nenni [username_date] => 0 [username_date_visible] => 0 [email] => dnenni@semiwiki.com [custom_title] => Admin [language_id] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [timezone] => America/Los_Angeles [visible] => 1 [activity_visible] => 1 [user_group_id] => 3 [secondary_group_ids] => 4,5,132 [display_style_group_id] => 3 [permission_combination_id] => 88 [message_count] => 13689 [question_solution_count] => 0 [conversations_unread] => 0 [register_date] => 1280720820 [last_activity] => 1748729203 [last_summary_email_date] => 1605968657 [trophy_points] => 113 [alerts_unviewed] => 99 [alerts_unread] => 99 [avatar_date] => 1663211649 [avatar_width] => 110 [avatar_height] => 107 [avatar_highdpi] => 0 [gravatar] => [user_state] => valid [security_lock] => [is_moderator] => 1 [is_admin] => 1 [is_banned] => 0 [reaction_score] => 6726 [warning_points] => 0 [is_staff] => 1 [secret_key] => 0HwyUVVHCwJotUUVEpvqAclfYJdGNPpw [privacy_policy_accepted] => 0 [terms_accepted] => 0 [vote_score] => 0 ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) [Forum] => XF\Entity\Forum Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 50 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Forum [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [discussion_count] => 7402 [message_count] => 51241 [last_post_id] => 86882 [last_post_date] => 1748748843 [last_post_user_id] => 14042 [last_post_username] => hist78 [last_thread_id] => 22909 [last_thread_title] => Foundry Monopoly in leading-edge Manufacturing: is it a real problem? [last_thread_prefix_id] => 0 [moderate_threads] => 0 [moderate_replies] => 0 [allow_posting] => 1 [count_messages] => 1 [find_new] => 1 [allow_index] => allow [index_criteria] => [field_cache] => [] [prefix_cache] => [] [prompt_cache] => [] [default_prefix_id] => 0 [default_sort_order] => last_post_date [default_sort_direction] => desc [list_date_limit_days] => 0 [require_prefix] => 0 [allowed_watch_notifications] => all [min_tags] => 0 [forum_type_id] => discussion [type_config] => {"allowed_thread_types":["poll"]} ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( [Node] => XF\Entity\Node Object ( [_uniqueEntityId:XF\Mvc\Entity\Entity:private] => 49 [rootClass:protected] => XF\Entity\Node [_useReplaceInto:protected] => [_newValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_values:protected] => Array ( [node_id] => 2 [title] => SemiWiki Main Forum ( Ask the Experts! ) [description] => Post your questions to the experts here! [node_name] => [node_type_id] => Forum [parent_node_id] => 1 [display_order] => 1 [display_in_list] => 1 [lft] => 2 [rgt] => 3 [depth] => 1 [style_id] => 0 [effective_style_id] => 0 [breadcrumb_data] => {"1":{"node_id":1,"title":"Main Category","depth":0,"lft":1,"node_name":null,"node_type_id":"Category","display_in_list":true}} [navigation_id] => [effective_navigation_id] => ) [_relations:protected] => Array ( ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [_previousValues:protected] => Array ( ) [_options:protected] => Array ( ) [_deleted:protected] => [_readOnly:protected] => [_writePending:protected] => [_writeRunning:protected] => [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_whenSaveable:protected] => Array ( ) [_cascadeSave:protected] => Array ( ) [_behaviors:protected] => ) ) [populated:protected] => 1 )
-
Foundry Monopoly in leading-edge Manufacturing: is it a real problem?
latest reply by hist78 onstarted by user nl on -
Pat Gelsinger: AI is a Moral Risk
latest reply by XYang2023 onstarted by Daniel Nenni on -
US restricts chip design software sales to China
latest reply by Paul2 onstarted by Daniel Nenni on -
US court blocks most Trump tariffs, says president exceeded his authority
latest reply by blueone onstarted by hist78 on -
Intel cuts pay to support the dividend
latest reply by Spreorke onstarted by blueone on -
Hitachi Electron Microscope View of a 5nm FinFET
latest reply by Fred Chen onstarted by Daniel Nenni on -
Who will dominate quantum computing and at what levels?
latest reply by Arthur Hanson onstarted by Arthur Hanson on -
More Semicon Reality - Renesas abandons SiC plan
latest reply by Paul2 onstarted by Barnsley on -
Earnings call transcript: NVIDIA beats Q1 2025 expectations
latest reply by Daniel Nenni onstarted by Daniel Nenni on -
Ukrainian Drones Target Russian Semiconductor Plant and Disrupt Internet Near Moscow
latest reply by Daniel Nenni onstarted by Daniel Nenni on
Recent Forum Threads
Recent Article Comments
Intel Foundry is a Low Risk Aternative to TSMC
intel cannot survive as a idm first. in order to get foundry businees they need to optimize for that. the…— Mark Webb on May 24, 2025Intel Foundry is a Low Risk Aternative to TSMC
Intel always has been and will always be an IDM. As an IDM 1st & foremost, they will be internal…— KEVIN on May 24, 2025Alchip’s Technology and Global Talent Strategy Deliver Record Growth
Alchip is a terrific company led by a driven & humble CEO (Johnny). Rajendiran, this line in your article ->…— akumar on May 22, 2025CEO Interview with Ido Bukspan of Pliops
Read this article and wondered if they actually delivered any concrete benefits. Fun to get an real world update a…— KevinK on May 21, 2025Intel Foundry is a Low Risk Aternative to TSMC
Yeah they are just moving Margin between Products and Foundry at this point.— siliconbruh999 on May 20, 2025Intel Foundry is a Low Risk Aternative to TSMC
What happened with Intel Foundry having its own CFO and Presenting out separate from products group? Since profitability is a…— Mark Webb on May 20, 2025Intel Foundry is a Low Risk Aternative to TSMC
running 30K test wafers is not really that big a deal... we have no idea what was actually run (it…— Mark Webb on May 20, 2025Intel Foundry is a Low Risk Aternative to TSMC
Yeah that's something the only advantage for Intel as of rn is US Fabs and TSMC is charging premium for…— siliconbruh999 on May 19, 2025Intel Foundry is a Low Risk Aternative to TSMC
I worry that if Intel gets close to a significant win on 18A or 14A, TSMC has the market dominance…— benb on May 19, 2025
Recent Podcast Episodes
Video EP7: The impact of Undo’s Time Travel Debugging with Greg Law
Podcast EP289: An Overview of How Highwire Helps to Deliver Advanced Fabs with Less Cost, Time and Risk with David Tibbetts
Podcast EP288: How Alphawave Semi Enables Next Generation Connectivity with Bharat Tailor
Video EP6: The Benefits of AI Agents for Waveform Debugging with Zackary Glazewski of Alpha Design
Podcast EP287: Advancing Hardware Security Verification and Assurance with Andreas Kuehlmann
Video EP5: A Discussion of Photonic Design Challenges and Solutions with Keysight
Video EP4: A Deeper Look at Advanced Packaging & Multi-Die Design Challenges with Anna Fontanelli
Podcast EP286: The Significant Impact of Ambient Scientific Technology on AI Deployment with GP Singh
Video EP3: A Discussion of Challenges and Strategies for Heterogeneous 3D Integration with Anna Fontanelli
Podcast EP285: The Post-Quantum Cryptography Threat and Why Now is the Time to Prepare with Michele Sartori
Speculative Execution: Rethinking the Approach to CPU Scheduling