Array
(
    [content] => 
    [params] => Array
        (
            [0] => /forum/threads/fear-and-resignation-after-%E2%80%98world%E2%80%99s-most-powerful-company%E2%80%99-pays-trump-a-100-billion-%E2%80%98protection-fee%E2%80%99.22315/
        )

    [addOns] => Array
        (
            [DL6/MLTP] => 13
            [Hampel/TimeZoneDebug] => 1000070
            [SV/ChangePostDate] => 2010200
            [SemiWiki/Newsletter] => 1000010
            [SemiWiki/WPMenu] => 1000010
            [SemiWiki/XPressExtend] => 1000010
            [ThemeHouse/XLink] => 1000970
            [ThemeHouse/XPress] => 1010570
            [XF] => 2021770
            [XFI] => 1050270
        )

    [wordpress] => /var/www/html
)

Fear and resignation after ‘world’s most powerful company’ pays Trump a $100 billion ‘protection fee’

Daniel Nenni

Admin
Staff member
TSMC CEO CC Wei, right, joins a press conference with President Donald Trump at the White House on March 3, 2025. - Andrew Harnik/Getty Images

TSMC CEO CC Wei, right, joins a press conference with President Donald Trump at the White House on March 3, 2025. - Andrew Harnik/Getty Images

It was a surprise ceremony at the White House presided over by President Donald Trump to unveil a $100 billion investment from what he called the world’s most powerful company, Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company (TSMC).

But nearly 8,000 miles away, the mood was far from celebratory. Instead, the shock announcement last week has reignited fears in Taiwan about losing its crown jewel, its world-beating semiconductor industry, to the US due to political pressure.

The island democracy’s former President Ma Ying-jeou wasted no time in accusing the ruling Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) of “selling TSMC” to Trump as a “protection fee.”

“This is a major national security crisis,” Ma, a member of the opposition Kuomintang (KMT), wrote on his Facebook page on March 4, shortly after the White House signing ceremony. It will “’have a significant negative impact on people’s confidence, cross-strait relations and Taiwan’s future geopolitical position.”

To reassure the public, Taiwan President Lai Ching-te appeared alongside TSMC CEO CC Wei last week at Taipei’s presidential office, saying the company’s US investment would not undermine its commitment to and planned expansion in its home base.

TSMC produces more than 90% of the world’s advanced microchips, which power everything from smartphones and artificial intelligence to weapons. That’s why many in Taiwan believe that global dependence on its semiconductors serves as a “silicon shield,” a deterrent against a potential Chinese invasion.

China’s ruling Communist Party claims Taiwan as part of its territory despite having never controlled it and has vowed to take control of the self-governing island, by force if necessary. Beijing has in recent years escalated its military activities around Taiwan, regularly flying fighter jets and conducting exercises in waters near the island.

A screen in Beijing shows news footage of military drills conducted by the Chinese People's Liberation Army around Taiwan on October 14, 2024. - Tingshu Wang/Reuters

A screen in Beijing shows news footage of military drills conducted by the Chinese People's Liberation Army around Taiwan on October 14, 2024. - Tingshu Wang/Reuters

‘Ukraine today, Taiwan tomorrow’​

Taiwan relies on US military and political support. Under the Taiwan Relations Act, the US is legally obligated to provide Taiwan with the means to defend itself against a possible attack by China.

But Trump’s recent rhetoric has cast uncertainty over the future of US-Taiwan relations. He has repeatedly accused Taiwan of “stealing” the US semiconductor industry, a claim that is widely disputed, while saying outright that Taiwan should pay the US for “protection.”

For many on the self-governing island, the phrase “Ukraine today, Taiwan tomorrow” has increasingly resonated in recent weeks as they watch Trump upend longstanding US policy by playing up Kremlin rhetoric and warming to Moscow, while alienating traditional European allies and Kyiv. Taiwanese see parallels between their democracy and Ukraine, with both facing existential threats from aggressive, expansionist neighbors.

Washington earlier this month abruptly suspended military aid to Ukraine following a heated exchange between Trump, Vice President JD Vance and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky at the White House, just hours after the cheerful TSMC ceremony. It reinstated aid this week after Ukraine accepted a 30-day US-proposed ceasefire. The White House has also pressed Zelensky to sign a deal giving the US access to Kyiv’s untapped mineral riches.

Tammy Chao, a retiree, expressed deep concern to CNN about Taiwan’s security after TSMC’s announcement, likening Trump’s approach to his handling of Ukraine. She described him as a “dealer” who might eventually treat Taiwan as a bargaining chip.

“Taiwan, pretty soon just like [what] he said to Zelensky, ‘you have no cards to play,’ and Taiwan is not gonna have cards to play,” she said. “TSMC was the best card.”
But others appear less concerned. Fred Lin, a finance industry professional, said he believed TSMC came to this decision prudently.

“Who doesn’t pay protection fees to the US? No doubt It is a form of protection fee, that we can understand, but that’s the reality of international politics,” he said.

TSMC headquarters in Hsinchu, Taiwan, in 2024 - I-Hwa Cheng/AFP/Getty Images

TSMC headquarters in Hsinchu, Taiwan, in 2024 - I-Hwa Cheng/AFP/Getty Images

Trump administration officials, however, have also said they need to dial down involvement in European security to focus on Asia – and the threat from China. Prior to his election, Vance was explicit in his concerns that US support for Ukraine could hinder its ability to aid Taiwan in the event of a Chinese attack.

Researchers say there are limits to comparisons between Ukraine and Taiwan’s security circumstances and believe the island’s security is influenced by multiple factors beyond its semiconductor industry, including China’s broader geopolitical ambition and Taiwan’s strategic location.

Whether China takes military action against Taiwan is ultimately driven by its core interests, which are not solely dependent on the island’s role in global chip production, said Min-yen Chiang, a nonresident fellow at the Research Institute for Democracy, Society, and Emerging Technology, a government-funded think tank in Taipei.

He referenced the time in 1950 when the US sent its Seventh Fleet to the Taiwan Strait early on during the Korean War to deter China from invading Taiwan. The strategic move by then-President Harry Truman neutralized the Taiwan Strait and ensured the Korean War did not trigger a wider conflict, maintaining stability in the Asia-Pacific region.
“Taiwan then had no semiconductor industry at all,” he said.

Still committed​

Last week, President Lai said Taipei did not “face any pressure from Washington” in doing the TSMC deal, which the company said was the biggest such investment in the US ever made by a non-American firm.

Standing next to him, Wei attributed the increased investment to “strong demand” from American customers such as Apple, Nvidia, AMD, Qualcomm and Broadcom that wanted to reduce potential supply chain risks by having chips made locally.

TSMC was awarded $6.5 billion in grants for its first three plants in Arizona under the bipartisan Chips Act, spearheaded by the Biden administration, which allocated $39 billion in federal funding to boost domestic semiconductor manufacturing.

“We are the best wherever we build our fabs,” Wei added, referring to semiconductor fabrication plants.

Along with the additional three manufacturing facilities, the new investment also promised two chip packaging plants and a research and development center to improve the production process technology.

Wei clarified that the development of the cutting-edge next generation chipmaking technology would remain in Taiwan and would still be 10 times bigger than the US facilities.

Semiconductor analysts applauded the company for making an “agile” decision.

TF International Securities analyst Ming-Chi Kuo praised TSMC in an online analysis, calling it the “most successful non-US company in negotiations with the Trump administration.”

“Though the $100 billion investment seems massive, the lack of details provides the flexibility for spending based on future conditions, softening the impact on profitability,” Kuo wrote.

TSMC’s investment has mostly alleviated Trump’s concerns, according to Eric Chen, an analyst at Digitimes Research, a market research firm. “But of course, we have no way of knowing when Trump might change his stance — he’s notorious for making sudden U-turns,” he said.

An electronic wafer is displayed at the TSMC Museum of Innovation in Hsinchu, Taiwan, in 2024. - I-Hwa Cheng/AFP/Getty Images

An electronic wafer is displayed at the TSMC Museum of Innovation in Hsinchu, Taiwan, in 2024. - I-Hwa Cheng/AFP/Getty Images

He also added that TSMC was “not afraid” of Trump potentially scrapping the subsidies from the Chips Act, stressing that the company’s decision to invest in the US was driven by customer needs.

Weaponizing tariffs​

TSMC’s $100 billion investment marks the latest in a wave of businesses committing massive sums to the US. But it stands out as one of the first major foreign firms to do so, and Trump claims more such investments are on the way.

In contrast to his predecessor Biden’s approach of incentivizing domestic investment through subsidies, Trump prefers to weaponize tariffs. So far, it has proven effective.

Trump has previously threatened to impose 25% tariffs on semiconductors, along with automobiles and pharmaceuticals as early as next month. At the announcement of TSMC’s investment, Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick said the company chose to expand in the US due to the threat of tariffs, and were not given additional grants.

In late February, Apple pledged $500 billion to expand facilities, manufacturing and projects across the US over the next four years. Oracle, OpenAI and SoftBank announced in January that they would invest $500 billion to create a new company that would build artificial intelligence infrastructure in the US.

With TSMC’s new investment in the US, Trump is expected to turn up the heat on other major companies, said Chang-Tai Hsieh, an economist at the University of Chicago’s Booth School of Business.

He said it puts added pressure on Samsung and Intel, the two other major producers of computing and AI chips in the world.

South Korea’s SK Hynix, another key player in memory chips along with Samsung, are also expected to feel the squeeze. Samsung has previously pledged to invest $37 billion in Texas, while SK Hynix announced plans to build a $3.87 billion chip packaging plant in Indiana last year. Samsung and SK Hynix declined to comment.

Hsieh said it is obvious that companies like TSMC and others will have to “do whatever they can to make Trump happy.” But he also warned of the risks associated with such concessions.

“Once you agree to blackmail, then there’s no end of it,” he said.

 
Unfortunate, but understandable.

If it keeps China from invading Taiwan in the next 4 years, it would be a good move. Trump won't be President in 5 years. How much of that commitment will actually be spent by then?


As much as I dislike Trump, and hate seeing countries and companies extorted, this seems like it could avoid something much more destructive.

It's sad it has come to this.
 
Do you think the US is really better off than 10 years ago? How about 20 years ago? It is not. Do you think the Ukraine war could have been prevented? Yes it could have. Instead we have poured billions of dollars into killing people. That is not okay. The world leaders who allowed this war to happen should be deeply ashamed and so should the people who continue to support them. The same goes for a conflict between China and Taiwan.

Look at the $36T+ US national debt. Do you think that is okay? It is not. What about the US trade deficit? The US had a $919 billion trade deficit in 2024 yet China had a $1T trade surplus in 2024? How do you fix that?

How about the homeless, drug, hate, and violence problems that surround us? I honestly fear for my grandchildren.

So how do you fix this? Small changes are not going to do it and we are running out of time. I have no idea if the current administration will fix this mess but I am certainly willing to entertain it.
 
Whether China takes military action against Taiwan is ultimately driven by its core interests, which are not solely dependent on the island’s role in global chip production, said Min-yen Chiang, a nonresident fellow at the Research Institute for Democracy, Society, and Emerging Technology, a government-funded think tank in Taipei.

quite agree
 
...
Look at the $36T+ US national debt. Do you think that is okay? It is not. What about the US trade deficit? The US has a $100B+ trade deficit yet China has a $100B+ trade surplus? How do you fix that?
...
Its much worse. Total Chinese trade surplus is 1T USD. 300B of that surplus is with US.

I think that this should be said in every conversation about global economy, tariffs... Because it looks like lot of people discussing it does not realize how serious situation is.
 
Its much worse. Total Chinese trade surplus is 1T USD. 300B of that surplus is with US.

I think that this should be said in every conversation about global economy, tariffs... Because it looks like lot of people discussing it does not realize how serious situation is.

China surplus per capita is what?
 
For many on the self-governing island, the phrase “Ukraine today, Taiwan tomorrow” has increasingly resonated in recent weeks as they watch Trump upend longstanding US policy by playing up Kremlin rhetoric and warming to Moscow, while alienating traditional European allies and Kyiv. Taiwanese see parallels between their democracy and Ukraine, with both facing existential threats from aggressive, expansionist neighbors.

It was very foolish even entertaining him, and his team in the previous term. They should've given him zero regard, and he would've eventually forgotten about it as such.

Now, a private entity became a third entity in the negotiations between states, likely to its own detriment.
 
TSMC is not important. Taiwan's location is what matters to the U.S. and its allies. Taiwan would only become another Ukraine if the U.S. stopped caring about Asia altogether. (The First island Chain)


Open a world map and look at Taiwan's position. If China took Taiwan, it would open up the Pacific for the Chinese Navy. U.S. allies like South Korea and Japan would be in a very vulnerable position, as China could disrupt trade and supply routes. Additionally, it would provide China with direct access to the broader Pacific Ocean, the Big Beautiful Ocean that Trump talked about.


This American understands the situation, just watch the video regarding the confirmation of the Deputy Secretary of Defense. (its in English)


Even U.S. senators recognize which party in Taiwan is cutting its military budget. Taiwan's security is ultimately in the hands of its own people. If they choose not to defend themselves, others won't help them—that’s the law of the jungle, and we are moving toward that.


For years, the EU has been lax on its own defense, assuming America would always carry them. Trump is not the first president to call for the EU to beef up its military, Clinton, Bush Jr., and Obama did. Trump was just blunt and bastard about it.


Taiwan is important because of its location, but its security is always in the hand of its people.
 
TSMC is not important. Taiwan's location is what matters to the U.S. and its allies. Taiwan would only become another Ukraine if the U.S. stopped caring about Asia altogether. (The First island Chain)


Open a world map and look at Taiwan's position. If China took Taiwan, it would open up the Pacific for the Chinese Navy. U.S. allies like South Korea and Japan would be in a very vulnerable position, as China could disrupt trade and supply routes. Additionally, it would provide China with direct access to the broader Pacific Ocean, the Big Beautiful Ocean that Trump talked about.


This American understands the situation, just watch the video regarding the confirmation of the Deputy Secretary of Defense. (its in English)


Even U.S. senators recognize which party in Taiwan is cutting its military budget. Taiwan's security is ultimately in the hands of its own people. If they choose not to defend themselves, others won't help them—that’s the law of the jungle, and we are moving toward that.


For years, the EU has been lax on its own defense, assuming America would always carry them. Trump is not the first president to call for the EU to beef up its military, Clinton, Bush Jr., and Obama did. Trump was just blunt and bastard about it.


Taiwan is important because of its location, but its security is always in the hand of its people.
Wow. So it is OK for the US to take over Canada?

I strongly disagree. None of this is in the best interest of the US. China invades Taiwan? BAD for the US (people thought the COVID chip supply was a big deal? This would DWARF it). Trade wars .... with EVERYONE? Hope you don't have a 401K plan and want to retire in the next few years! US Economy? Say goodbye to those low unemployment rates.

Trade wars are just stupid. Tariffs are just an unconstitutional TAX on the American people (seriously look it up. Tariffs aren't even IN the constitution).

IMO, people that support Trump are going to be just like 14 year old girls 20 years ago that LOVED the back street boys. A decade from now, hardly a soul will admit they were part of this madness.
Do you think the Ukraine war could have been prevented?
No. It could not. That road was paved with Georgia and Crimea. The only thing that will prevent Russia from invading other countries now is a world war. The US could have stopped it easily after Ukraine was invaded simply by providing ~250Bn in medium range weapons and the intelligence to use them effectively to shut down Russia's war production.

.... and that 250bn is cheap compared to what this recession is going to cost ..... and the recession caused when Europe goes to war with Russia. It will seem like chump change then.
But it only costs $100M to,Trump’s campaign fund for a presidential ad for your products on the White House lawn.
Got to love that "Citizens United" decision eh?

Seems like Elon is losing MUCH more than 100M due to his association with the Trump administration. That boy forgot which side of the bread his butter was on. But then, I don't think this is about money anymore. It's about power and influence. After all, what do you give the guy that has "everything"?
How about the homeless, drug, hate, and violence problems that surround us? I honestly fear for my grandchildren.
... as do I. We are looking at the FIRST generation of kids in the US that are NOT expected to do as well as their parents. I guess we have to make sure the rich keep getting richer eh?
I have no idea if the current administration will fix this mess but I am certainly willing to entertain it.
Sadly, the current administration seems hell bent on diving the US into a recession led by incredible inflation and a bunch of world conflicts. Kill off R&D? Sure, why not? Kill off the ability of the IRS to function? Sure. Demonize one half of Americans against the other half of Americans? Declare war against our closest allies? Make friends and defend dictators? I served for 6 years to keep that insane KGB ridden psychopath Putin and those like him away from the people of the US. I personally find it sickening where we are today.

It is our kids and their kids that will pay the price I fear, and the butchers bill will be large indeed.
 
Back
Top