(Curiosity) Question -
Assuming you don’t have very high performance needs (i.e. a lot of transistors at high speed and/or low power), I think that FPGAs vs ASIC is generally a volume and cost decision. With a lot of focus on ‘very old’ nodes being used by automakers and such, and hints from foundries that they want those designers to switch to more modern nodes for their ASICs - is there a point where a super cheap, but modern fabbed FPGA could be used to replace those old ASICs instead?
.. or does this never make sense if you have any substantial volume (say 100K+ units, of any size)? I.e. Even though the cost per transistor is a lot lower on say a 14nm node than a 130nm node, the difference between the two nodes doesn’t allow the FPGA cost to drop sufficiently to make up for it? (I.e. FPGA on a ‘modern’ process - sub-28nm vs. an ASIC on 130nm or so).
Is there another type of ‘generic programming logic chip’ besides FPGA that might bridge a gap like that? I.e. ‘just buy this [non-ASIC] chip on a modern node “for cheap” vs. design your own ASIC on that modern node dealing with mask, yield respins, and other unique costs?.
Assuming you don’t have very high performance needs (i.e. a lot of transistors at high speed and/or low power), I think that FPGAs vs ASIC is generally a volume and cost decision. With a lot of focus on ‘very old’ nodes being used by automakers and such, and hints from foundries that they want those designers to switch to more modern nodes for their ASICs - is there a point where a super cheap, but modern fabbed FPGA could be used to replace those old ASICs instead?
.. or does this never make sense if you have any substantial volume (say 100K+ units, of any size)? I.e. Even though the cost per transistor is a lot lower on say a 14nm node than a 130nm node, the difference between the two nodes doesn’t allow the FPGA cost to drop sufficiently to make up for it? (I.e. FPGA on a ‘modern’ process - sub-28nm vs. an ASIC on 130nm or so).
Is there another type of ‘generic programming logic chip’ besides FPGA that might bridge a gap like that? I.e. ‘just buy this [non-ASIC] chip on a modern node “for cheap” vs. design your own ASIC on that modern node dealing with mask, yield respins, and other unique costs?.